zabor, I put a good couple of years into trying to answer this question. Started out absolutely totally convinced surround is the way to go, and the way to do it is with a AVR. That lasted about a month. What I did, went and listened to AVRs in stores. Every time I would listen to something similar for stereo, usually a similarly priced integrated amp. Every single time the integrated was so much better I could hardly believe it.
Okay but still I am convinced of the absolute necessity of surround for movies. So I spent at least a year looking at surround separates. Separate processors. These are all awful too. At one point I had brought one home and it was so bad it was not even necessary to compare but we did, and my 30 year old Kenwood KA6008 smoked it by so much my wife said no way.
Yet still I was determined. Even went to the point of running full range surrounds, same speakers L/R front and rear. Using a separate stereo amp for the surrounds. This was awfully good for movies and unlike all the others didn’t harm stereo music quality. Except for one thing. I realized all this money going into surround was wasted in the sense it wasn’t really improving movies, but it was taking away from music.
That is why after years of trying everything I finally threw in the towel on "Home Theater" at least in the sense of being dogmatically obsessed with surround. Turns out when the stereo is good the sound stage is so compelling you get lost in the movie and forget all about the lack of gimmicky special effects whizzing overhead and behind.
If you like that great, allocate to your heart’s content. Just be sure it really is your heart and not your programmed by mass marketing need for validation and herd approval you are content with.
https://systems.audiogon.com/systems/8367