Mephisto II, Sim Moon Eclipse How do they compare?

Thank you Brian, your input was very helpful. It's going to be a very tough call as both players are not only some of the best looking around, they both offer the features I'm looking for. From what I read on the Sim Moon Eclipse, the older version had HDCD decoding, the new version does not. Would you recommend getting the newer player over the older one with HDCD? And if so why? Also, what is a good used price to look for on a Sim Moon Eclipse? From what you've told me and from the reviews I've read, the Sim Moon Eclipse is one heck of a fine CD player. Might be just what I'm looking for.

BTW, sounds like you've got one awesome setup. Fine choices in audio gear. I'll bet it sounds great!

Thank you again.

Camboinc,

Thank you very much for your most helpful input. The Sim seems to be one heck of a player. If I can I would prefer to get the newer version without the HDCD chip. I have a question, does it make a difference getting the full size PSX power supply instead of the one that comes standard with the unit. And thanks also for letting me know about BNC cables (if I get an older Eclipse this will be very important). Thanks again and I'm happy to hear that you're really enjoying your Sim :)

Kops,

Thanks for the info, it's going to be tough deciding between these two very fine players.

Camboinc,

Yeah, that 10/10 Sim Eclipse for $2000 was quite a deal. It didn't last too long either. The ad was only there for a day and it was Gon. I really like the idea of the full size PSX power supply. I like the way it looks with the player, and it making it sound even better is icing on the cake. So if I find a newer Eclipse that doesn't have the HDCD chip, should I steer clear of the PSX power supply?

I really appreciate all the helpful input you've givin me. Thanks.

Fmpnd,

Bose Wave Radio and a Mattel "Close & Play" Record Player with a $6,000 power cord....kool!! I want one too :)

Seriously, I know you guy's have got some kick butt systems. I haven't seen any pictures of Brian's setup, but I can only imagine. I checked out your setup and geez what an awesome system it is. It's no wonder Brian likes to borrow cables, if I had a friend like you, I'd be doing the same thing :) Very, very, nice system you've got, I'll bet it sounds awesome!

I just want to say thank you for your most welcome input. The Moon Eclipse sounds like a winner, and I would definitely welcome one in my listening room. Thanks for the laughs also :)

Camboinc,

If I find one with the PSX power supply at a really good price that will be the way to go. But if I see an Eclipse with the standard power supply in excellent condition at a price I just can't refuse......

Yes, that Frank is great. Bose and Mattel, he cracks me up. So that's why he picks on you, as he's a Bose enthusiast as well :) Seriously, he has one awesome setup. Those speakers are absolutely beautiful, and all that exotic gear really compliments them. It's definitely one of the nicest systems I've ever seen. When I saw the pix all I could do was drool :)

Thanks Brian for all your help, I really appreciate it.

Transporter,

Geeez, you again! Only kidding :) Thanks for chiming in. Buy the Sim huh? Yeah the Sim seems like the logical choice, but, it's a tough call as both are first rate players. But I'm strongly leaning towards the Sim. Thanks for the post, It's great! Gotta love it.

Camboinc,

Thanks Brian, I will definitely let you know when I score one. Yep, gotta keep that Frank in line :) Cheers!

Fmpnd,

Man, all this talk about Bose, Mattel, and 8 tracks has really got me wanting to join this elite club of yours and Brians. Where can I sign up. I don't have Bose or Mattel (I can get em'), but I do think I have an vintage 8 track laying around somewhere :) It'll be like a retro flashback to the 70's. Groovy man!

Thanks for the laughs Frank, It's great!

Darrylhifi,

My my, to what do we owe this honor? Just when I thought you had fallen off the face of the earth.... Good to hear from you. And you can tell Guido to forget about coming to the southwest because the Sim is currently in the lead. So get a grip :)