Meadowlark Swift vs. Soliloquy vs. Concertinos

Since my last post ,I have listened to the Concertinos. I think they a terrific speakers.But from all that I've heard the Soliloquys are still the better value and give up nothing in performance out of the 3 makers listed.The Sonus Fabers are beautiful speakers but over priced IMHO.

Thats a fair reply and thought. It is possible that the set up of the room and gear hindered the abilities of the concertinos during my audition. Frankly, I was expecting more based on what I read.

I still favor the Soliloquy line as a whole, but hey, thats what its all about. Lots of good speakers folks to choose from

I will have to differ with Rysa4 on the Concertinos. I owned a pair and still regret selling them as I have a small listening room and acheived a "magic" sound with them. The Meadowlarks are nice too and will give you more low end. Again, the concertinos when paired with the correct electronics and wire, are wonderful and just seem to get the pitch "right" with solid imaging and soundstaging.

I sold my Concertinos for a pair of Tyler Taylo Reference Monitors as an ugrade. Honestly, I missed the Sonus sound so much, I sold the Taylos and now own Sonus Faber Concerto Homes with the adjustable stands.

The Soliloquys in my oppinion are okay but miss the mark when it comes to the total package. If you buy the Concertinos, feel free to e-mail me as I have a few tricks on setting them up. Good Luck!

Chris

This htread is a bit old but I see a recent response! I have auditioned the concertinos and Soliloquy stuff. I have never heard the meadowlark line unfortunately. The concertinos are a distant third in that line up. I would actually think that a comparison between the Soliloquy sat 5s vs the concertinos is more appropriate, and the sat 5s win there too IMHO. Smoother, mid, highs, and lows more accurately reproduced, even bass sounds better with the Solilquy SAt5s although not sure how. The 5.0s are a different class and are a much better value than Sonus Faber Concertinos.

I have the Soliloquy 5.0's with the matching stands powered by the AR Complete. I love it. Its a perfect match. Have had them about a month. I had some initial issues with the Soliloquy stands (full mat pad was sucking out much of the mid-bass energy and warmth and made the midrange sound thin), but I've placed another metal plate on top (decouples?)and they sound just terrific.

My cabinets are last year's, but outfitted with the new drivers-crossover-insulation. The Sonic Room in Durham, NC bought up the old cabinet stock from Soliloquy and will have the factory build them up for you with the stands for literally about 1/2 price. Call Pete Sylvester about them. I'm still smiling....and loving the sound!

Chris

I have owned the Soliloquy 6.2's and the Meadowlark Ospreys (both next step up speakers in the line) and auditioned the 5.0's, the 5.3's and the swift in the past. I would say the largest difference if you stated you are mainly looking for acoustics and vocals, is that the Soliloquy's are going to "seem" a bit more forward and pronounced in detail and such when you audition them. The Swifts will tend to seem a bit more laid back and perhaps not as "exciting." I say this due to having lived with both manufacturers, and what caught me on the Soliloquy's up front as a bit more engaging eventually wore on me as not quite as natural once placed in my listening room at home over time. The Meadowlark's on the other hand, didn't tend to overly "impress" me in the store, as nothing jumped out at me, but after listening to them extensively in home for over a year, they have a VERY natural timbre, harmonic presentation and tone. I think this is mainly due to factors such as being time aligned drivers, first order crossovers, and transmission line bass. The bass is also much more articulate and tuneful due to the transmission line, and not as bloated in certain frequencies as I have experienced with Soliloquys. If the Meadowlarks are set up properly, they will soundstage like champs, vocals much more natural and pure than any speaker under $1000 should sound like, and tuneful bass that belies its cabinet. With that being said, pay attention that you aren't placing them in too large of a room. All of my experience was done in home with Unison Research Unico (80 wpc) on both the 6.2's and Ospreys, I did hear the swifts also with VTL integrated and the Soliloquys with a couple different integrateds (in which I can not remember for sure). I have no experience at all with the Concertinos to comment.

I honestly cannot comment on the Solilquy, but I do own the Swift's, powered by 2 Bryston 2b's and a Blue Circle pre. The biggest factor is room size and placement. If the room is too big, the Swifts will soound weak on the bottom end. I love the Swifts, actually one of the best sounding speakers I have ever heard (In the Price Range), they replaced a pair of maggie 1.6's the room was just to small to let the maggies breath. If your dealer can let you take a pair to try, it would be your best solution.

I guess as far as the power conditioning goes it depends,which ever pleases you most.I can't tell the difference with my amp being plugged into a power conditioner but my cd-p is a different story.Yeap that's what I heard with the Swifts,they were a little rolled off on the top end.The 5.0s are some great little speakers.They are extremely open and airy.It will take 400 or 500 hrs of playing time to really hear them.But once you get use to the open sound it will be hard to look at another speaker.I cannot rememer if they are biwireable.But if so I would advise you to biwire them.I have tried it both ways and there is a definite difference.I want even listen to my 6.3s unless they are biwired.Listening to vocals and acoustic music or any other kind ,you really can't go wrong with the Soliloquys.Hope this helps!

Sorry, I guess I should have specified. I am looking at the Soliloquy 5.0 w/stands. I have been auditioning the Swifts the last couple of days and have found them very engaging but lacking that very last bit of detail. I know this is a little off subject but I have been playing with my power cord setup and this is making a huge difference. I am using a Audio Power Pack II with Audio Power PK 313's(i think) Should the power cable to the Int. Amp go straight into the wall or through the line conditioner?

I heard some Meadowlarks just the other day.They sounded ok but it could have been the gear, a VTL intergrated and a Rega planet.It lacked the last bit of air on the cymbals that I'am use to.I found I had to turn up the volume to really hear the soundstage.The midrange is really good on these speakers.The Solilquys sound more physical to me with more air and weight to the music.Midrange is on par with the Meadowlarks .It's hard to say what will match up with your gear.I'am not familiar with the Concertinos and can't comment on them.Which model of Soliloquy are you looking at? This will make it a little easier.

I've had almost the identical setup. I got rid of the Meadowlarks cause I couldn't make them sound the way everyone said they should. I much prefered the B&W CDM 1 NT with my audio refinement. Especially for vocals and acoustics. In fact, I'm trying to get rid of my Revels to go back to the CDM 1's. Hope this helps.