Manual preamp volume control - Audible Illusions M3B


Is it true that most preamps with remote control have a lot to do with their sound quality?
Do vintage preamps with manual precision volume control have the inherent advantage over modern preamps with remote control?
After a few months of mulling over preamp upgrade, I took a plunge on Audible Illusions M3B preamp after reading some posts on the advantage of manual volume control over remote.
Some, including Michael Fremer, considered AI M3A was one of the best preamp.
" All of this adds up to what is clearly one of the finest-sounding, best-built full-function preamplifiers in the world—and the reviews from around the world reflect that."
https://www.stereophile.com/tubepreamps/316/index.html

M3B is considered much better than M3A. AI still produces M3B (preamp with MM phono) and M3B MC (phono for low output) with no remote control.
If the answer to my two questions are true, when most super charged audiophiles search for holy grails, why they choose preamps with remote control over those with manual control, and prefer convenience over sound quality?


ihcho

Showing 3 responses by stereo5

I went from a Modulus 3B to a McIntosh tube preamp for 3 reasons. First was customer service from AI is almost non-existence and as Art Ferris is way up there in age, I worried what would happen when he passes. Second was I am getting very lazy in my old age and wanted a full function tube preamp with a remote. Third was I had a Modulus 3 and a 3A before the 3B and was tired of the AI and wanted to try a different brand.
The Mac tube preamp in my system is the best and last preamp I will purchase. One of the big problems with all the Modulus series preamps was it put out way too much gain. The highest I could set the volume lever was at 10 O Clock which did not give me much of a volume range and when they went with the stepped controls when the 3A came out, it was worse. That was my biggest gripe. My second biggest gripe was the tube hiss that came and went over and over and I always used the tubes recommended by AI.

The John Curl MC gold preamp in my 3A and 3B was better than the MC preamp in my Mac pre.  That is the only area that the Modulus was better than the Mac. The Mac has an ease I didn’t get with the AI plus it is dead quiet.  My preamp has 6 tubes and I can Jack the volume wide open with out any hiss, not even a peep.