#2 Solti on London is gripping. Agree on the Elly Ameling Haitink 4th and Horenstein 3rd. But honestly Mahler is better on digital due to the huge dynamic range and the unavoidability of ticks and pops distracting during the pianissimos.
You must listen to the Zander #6 and #9 with the Boston Philharmonic Youth Orchestra.
Mahler on vinyl - your favorite
The only one I own at this point is the 4th by Analog Productions with Fritz Reiner/Chicago Symphony.
What are your favorite Mahler symphonies on vinyl? Looking to add to the record collection.
Thanks!