LP to CD transfer question...what's best?

I use a stand alone burner when I transfer lossless files from my computer to CD. I typically use HHB or Mitsui Gold blanks. As for LPs, I continue to play them, but I have a modified Alesis ML9600 that can take the analog signal from my phono stage, record it to the HD, then allow me to burn a CD. No computer involved. I tried this for someone who wanted to have some LPs transfered to CD and it worked fine. I thought the quality pretty good.

You should definitely use an stand alone A/D. I use an ART DI/O which feeds the signal into my sound card. Generally, the A/D on the sound card is inferior to an external one.

Don't expect your CD burn to be as good as the L.P original.I also plug straight into the soundcard direct from the phono stage.Ultimately the bandwidth of CD can only be downsampling the more extended range of the L.P i.e a limit of 22.05Khz for CD as opposed to about 35Khz for the average commercial L.P.The best thing to do is to eliminate as many clicks and pops as possible by burning good quality L.P's.

I second DMinches views - an ART DI/O makes great copies when used as an a/d. Also you can dial in some tube warmth as required . Software is also a potential issue - I find Acon Digital's Acoustica to be good- cheap and supportive of 96khz recording.
Another potential route is to go USB in - there are some interesting posts at positive feedback in this regard. In short, going digital before the computer seems to be the way.

Question for Stefanl....Why is the sample rate limited to 22.05 when red bood CD is 44.1? If you use a A-D converter wouldn't it transfer at the rate set by the converter? Or by the computer software setting? Just curious. Thanks

Sorry if I wasn't clear owing to my bad use of language but that is what you actually get on a CD- 22.05Khz at the upper limit,it is rolled-off above this point and there is no data.Actually it is postulated that it is closer to about 17.5Khz to 18.5Khz in reality,after all the processing involved.The basic theory is that you sample at twice the required rate(44.1Khz) to get an error free sample in the given audible(?)range.Taken in 1980 to be only 20Hz-20Khz for us humans.You always sample at twice the rate you want in the audible band for digital.The rate of sampling and your actual bandwidth are two diffent things.Another point is that for CD it is actually better to sample at 44.1Khz all the way through and not sample at a higher rate i.e 96Khz from the analog signal,as the subsequent downsampling from the higher rate yields inferior results.