Low-sensitivity speakers — What's special about them?


I'm building a system for a smaller room (need smaller bookshelves), and I did a bunch of research and some listening. I am attracted both to the Dynaudio Evoke 10's (heard locally) and the Salk Wow1 speakers (ordered and I'm waiting on them for a trial). I have a Rel 328 sub.

Here's the thing — both of those speakers are 84db sensitivity. Several people on this forum and my local dealer have remarked, "You should get a speaker that's easier to drive so you have a wider choice of power and can spend less, too."

That advice — get a more efficient speaker — makes sense to me, but before I just twist with every opinion I come across (I'm a newbie, so I'm pathetically suggestible), I'd like to hear the other side. Viz.,

QUESTION: What is the value in low sensitivity speakers? What do they do for your system or listening experience which make them worth the cost and effort to drive them? Has anyone run the gamut from high to low and wound up with low for a reason?

Your answers to this can help me decide if I should divorce my earlier predilections to low-sensitivity speakers (in other words, throw the Salks and Dyns overboard) and move to a more reasonable partner for a larger variety of amps. Thanks.
128x128hilde45

Showing 1 response by almarg

In the case of dynamic (box-type) speakers, as a general rule of thumb small physical size, deep bass extension, and efficiency trade off against one another. So among the kind of small "bookshelf" speakers you are interested in more efficient speakers will tend to have less deep bass extension than less efficient speakers. There are many exceptions, of course, but as I say that set of tradeoffs can be considered to be a general rule of thumb.

And regarding deep bass extension, especially in the case of smaller speakers, some users will prefer to augment that with powered subwoofers, while some will not due to space or other considerations.

Other tradeoffs are also involved, of course. Larger cabinets tend to cost more than smaller cabinets, everything else being equal. The impedance characteristics of a speaker can affect drive difficulty as much or more than efficiency or sensitivity. (If Stereophile has reviewed a speaker that is under consideration the measurements section of the review will be very informative in that regard). Amplifiers tend to sound better when driving high impedances than when driving low impedances. For a given level of amplifier quality, and within a given class of operation (A, AB, or D) higher powered amplifiers tend to cost more than lower powered amplifiers. So within a given class of operation a greater percentage of the dollars one chooses to invest in an amplifier will tend to go toward quality rather than toward watts if high efficiency speakers are used.

And of course how all of these factors are addressed comes down to individual preference and budget. Personally I prefer relatively large floor-standing speakers having relatively high efficiency and benign impedance characteristics, which therefore are very versatile with respect to amplification. But the opposite approach works well for many others.

Good luck. Regards,
-- Al