Looking for a great front ported bookshelp speaker recommendation


Hi everyone,

After about a 15 year hiatus from hifi, I'm looking to get back into it. I'm looking for a front ported bookshelf speaker. The reason is that it's going to go inside a cabinet and right against a back wall. My budget is up to $5,000 but the less, the better:) Any advice or guidance would be appreciated.

TIA

blackiridium

Showing 2 responses by panzrwagn

The basic issue is that most speakers are not designed to load into an acoustic half-space and that creates a rise in low and mid-bass most will perceive as thickness or muddiness. Proximity to the rear wall also reduces reflection time from the back wall which tends to reduce the sense of spaciousness and depth of the stereo image, AKA soundstage. The original Boston Acoustics A-100, a notably flat and wide speaker, was designed to be placed against the back wall, and used that to good effect. Predictably, they sounded thin - lacking in bass - when pulled away from the wall. Many speakers use rear ports to augment low bass, leveraging the proximity. Similarly, their rear-ported bookshelf speakers only need an inch or so of clearance function as designed.

The other issue is room size. Most bookshelf speakers will have a peak output of around 106-108dB @ 1w/1m. That sounds like a lot until the inverse square law kicks in and output drops 6dB every time the distance doubles. So, at 4M (13 ft) their max loudness is 96 dB, and max average level (general rule of thumb) is 12dB below that or 84dB. Not very loud. Somehow you need to find at least 6dB of peak output or 114dB to really work in your room. All that points to JBL and the 4329P powered 8". It meets the size, placement, and out requirements for your room better than anything else available and if you haven't heard JBLs in awhile, these are not the boom/shriek JBLs of old. Checkout the reviews.

@blackiridium re: "So the ATC and Proac models wouldn't be loud enough?"

Those pesky Laws of Physics again. If you review the calculations I made, you need a speaker with a peak output capability of around 114dB. The other wise great ProAc D2R is rated at 88.5 dB sensitivity and 100-150W power handling. OK, 100W is 20 dBW, 150 about 21.5 dBW. So 88.5 plus 21.5 = 110 dB peak output. At the estimated listening position of 4M you lose 12dB of level due to the Inverse Square law. 110-12 = 98dB Peak level. allowing the 12dB Average to peak level, leaves us at 86dB max listening level before the system will sound strained. 

The also otherwise great ATC is described on the ATC website "The SCM20PSL is ATC’s flagship 2-way stand-mount loudspeaker and is the ideal choice in modestly sized rooms, but where performance cannot be compromised." It is rated at a peak out put of 108dB per pair from 80-20Khz, and -6dB (peak 102dB) from 55Hz so their numbers are even lower than mine. and your assessment regarding being light in the bass is correct.

The point here is this: a 6" bookshelf simply can't move enough air for realistic playback levels of practically any music type in a room of your size. An 8" woofer will give about 3dB more output, and the JBLs are engineered for maybe 3dB more output than most.