BS, no. BS is when some do not believe and or cannot hear a difference they think they know everyone else cannot either so call BS when it is they who are full of it, that is a bully with BS issues.
Yes, reducing reflections will make a difference and only you can determine at the base level that you like it or not and make changes until you do.
Also the fact when you make yourself more comfortable with physical or mental objectives then you are free to hear things from a more open perspective. That is why turning down of turning off the lights works so well, also why best to cover bright lights on your gear.
And, if possible, dedicated listening space well isolated from outside noise.
Your observations are spot on, there is a difference and you can hear it and like it, that is all that maters, not what some choose to make disparaging remarks about.
Rick