I changed my policy before I moved to increase the insurance on these items given that the equipment and records were going to be handled by movers (though I used specialty craters for the gear that didn’t have wooden shipping crates and packed the records myself). A few additional thoughts- you said insuring ’the room’- if you have special materials like acoustic treatment, flooring, electrical, etc, all of that goes beyond the norm too; when we’ve insured our homes, in each case an agent came after the policy was in place to do an on site inspection and adjust the value to reflect the replacement cost of the construction, special architectural or historical details, etc.
I also found that the high end insurers are in some cases cheaper for this stuff than the mainstream insurers. I first learned this with high value cars- the mainstream insurer wanted crazy money to insure, the high end insurer covered a Ferrari for less than the cost of our Volvo. And they are generally better to work with too. A broker who handles different underwriters can, with the information in hand, shop your needs to get the best quote among good insurers.
I believe, but am not sure, that a key factor in pricing is claims regarding auto insurance. Seems like the tail wagging the dog, but that’s my understanding. Most of these insurers want to do all coverage, including a liability umbrella. Doing the first exotic car led us down this path many years ago, and since then, we have remained with essentially the same insurer (though we’ve changed brokers over the years).
I did a detailed inventory of the LPs while I was packing them. Not every record, but the high value or rare ones, including catalog lists where I had most of a catalog (striking out the ones I didn’t own). The insurer then worked with me to develop a formula to average the value and hence, the overall coverage. The records were one tranche, the hi-fi gear another, the musical instruments and associated amps yet another, and other miscellaneous high value objects were scheduled on yet another list. You still have to prove loss, but it makes it a lot easier, along with the photo records others have mentioned.
The cost is not insignificant, and I am going through the process or reassessing the coverage now that the move is complete. It’s not that any of this stuff is of less value, but in some ways is at slightly different risk, now that it is back in my possession and control.
I also found that different brokers may be worth exploring, not so much due to price, but attitude and personal approach. Some of these brokers are stiffs and used to working with the wealthy, taking on a different attitude (which I didn’t necessarily find helpful) than others, who are less scripted. I want someone who I can work with easily and who ’gets’ it. You’d be surprised at the difference in comfort level you get just based on personality and the willingness of the broker/agent to bore down and work in depth with you to come up with the best solution. My experience with Chubb/Ace/Chubb has been extremely positive over more than two decades. There are others, like Pure, which I haven’t used that are also in the ’luxe goods’ high roller category. You should seek out a broker that can shop various of these types of underwriters.
While you are at it, also think about estate planning. If you go before your partner, the partner may be clueless. Just knowing who to contact (which may change over time) can be helpful if they want to dispose of this stuff. Ditto in your wills and associated estate plans. A third party executor will be clueless- at a minimum, the stuff should be called out and something included to have the executor search out specialty brokers for resale. (If both you and your partner expire simultaneously in a circumstance that does not impact the insured objects).