@erik_squires Morning. Thanks again for things to try. I'll look more into the "gated measurements" method. I'll also look into OmniMic. REW is really incredibly powerful program (free even!), and I think can be used even at a very surface level to help gain some objective info. In my system/room at home REW helped me figure out exactly what frequencies were making bass boom, which helped me make some parametric EQ changes. If you get time you should give it a look.
Father is SUPER sensitive to bass, so for him little bass is perfectly ok to him.There is no way he will move his speakers (he can be, 'intractable'? about some things). As we discussed, big goal is getting rid of the room echo/delay/reverb to a more moderate-mild level. Like you noted, that alone will bring up the level or presence of existing bass.
AM Acoustics Room Mode Simulator: I meant to say thanks for this!!! I had found that awhile ago and forgot about it and where to find it!! This is super helpful!
@mijostyn I think if I can get him to do even moderate absorbing panels, it will make sizeable improvements that he will like. I think the space COULD be perfect/exemplary and world class acoustically, but like we all know do we want to go thru the effort labor and expense? In his space, it wouldn't take much really since there is no bass management issues (other than the lack of it!!!! :D )
But maybe I can talk him into a subwoofer at some point! But these things take careful progress. I think as we get older in ways we can become sort of set and resistant to things....even if we heard a difference, and even if that difference were 'objectively better'.
And Erik is 100% correct about the bass coming out-- in putting absorbing panels directly inline with the face of the speakers and in-between, (so imagine 2, 2x4 insulation panels on chairs right and left of each speaker, and 4 of them in the 7' space between the speakers again 'in line' with the face of the speaker), you can easily hear a LOT fuller tone and sound, "as if you did an EQ boost in bass frequencies"......however, get this.....in doing a REW frequency sweep at the seated position, there was NO change in bass room frequency response! Yet, you can easily hear maybe 15% more "bass"!!
-----"Also, we want the room to interact a little. Diffuse sounds with a steady decay are really important to avoid a headphone-like experience and give us the illusions of the listening venue."--- as Erik notes here, the above treatment I did in fact created a bit of this effect: it was JARRING (in context)! I played a familiar track for him and removed the panels fast, and you can hear almost a pressure decrease in your ears.
I think with how much I would bet my father would actually agree to do acoustic treatment wise, he would correct 30-40% of the room echo reverb, and gain maybe 20% more mid bass presence.
In-Room responce measurement with Legacy Focus SE speakers
Evening all,
Odd request or question for folks with Legacy Focus SE speakers. I am doing some VERY casual speaker tests and room response measurements of dads big system. I have Legacy's smaller Studio HD bookshelf speakers, and have a VERY small space and I think they are incredible. In hearing my dad's much larger room/speakers/system (his listening room is literally the size of my tiny home!) with his larger Legacy Focus SE speakers.....I am honestly a bit underwhelmed, especially considering I have the 1/8th size Studios, and in my room/system they sound incredible.
In my home, the Studio bookshelf speakers sound 'mostly' full, warm, very taunt and articulate, and there is the right match of the tone of most all instruments and it's "weight". Like the pluck or strum of a guitar that is percussive, actually has a bit of an impact on your body. However, my dads system lacks this 'impact' or body and weight. Listening at 70-75decibell level is actually grating and feels like your head is being a bit compressed, but it doesn't "sound loud". My dad mentioned he usually doesn't play anywhere above 60ish decibels because of this issue.
Attached (I hope) is a screen shot of REW in room measurement of my system with the Studio HD bookshelf speakers for reference to what I am hearing. In my fathers system, there is a pronounced 100-130hz peak/hump and things sort of trail off rapidly in BOTH higher and lower frequencies. I'm trying to get a similar measurement to illustrate, but thought I would try to get some thoughts first.
Thanks for time!!
Showing 26 responses by amtprod
@erik_squires no I am thinking you are right: there is for sure a bigger need to get the speakers and room mechanically properly tuned: I don't think ANY EQ or DSP would bring out what the speakers are properly capable. Chances are all those things would do is create distortion somewhere else. |
https://www.flickr.com/photos/amtproductions/53619694364/in/dateposted-public/Thanks for the ideas @carlsbad2 That is a great idea, but unfortunately I am visiting the folks on the other side of the country from where I live, so no go on narrowing the scientific method testing with the exact same gear (smart idea though). My system: |
@erik_squires and @mashif thanks for the input on reflections. I was wondering a little about that as well, but I discounted it because of the size of the room (to me) is huge vs the speakers in them. You're right, if I stand near-inbetween the speakers I get a better full range of tones. The speakers are several feet away from boundaries and each other. However, there really is very very little in 'furnishings; his listening room is a huge finished basement. It doesn't 'echo' per-se, but it's not like a living room with lots to break up sound. |
@erik_squires that is EXACTLY what I was wondering, and you articulated all of it perfectly. In my little living room space, at very normal levels (50-60db), you can still feel the weight of a guitar pluck from low to high strings, and feel metallic strikes, etc. With his, you hear the note or the pluck....but that's it...you hear it's 'note', and nothing else. You may 'hear' a finger drag along a string, but you don't feel the sound like on my system/room. It's almost like I want to put a bunch of big subs everywhere to 'feel' notes/frequencies....not just bass. |
Morning @fthompson251 I sure can. Integrated amp: Rega Ellicit Mk4. CD Player & DAC: Rega Saturn. Streamer: iFi Zen Stream. Speaker wire: Deulund (12'). Turn table: Rega Planar 3. |
@mijostyn "Sibilant' is a very good descriptive word for what his room/speaker set up sounds like to me. As mentioned, to my ears it sounds as if the woofers aren't even functioning. It's funny you mention about getting an anechoic effect by taking the speakers outside: I had done that at work one summer for our fire crew (we have big old crappy yamaha tower speakers in our gym), and the sound was HORRIBLE. |
@elliottbnewcombjr Thanks for the idea and links for things! This is exactly what I am wanting to do, using Room EQ Wizard (REW) just to get a very crude general idea of what the speaker is doing at the listening position with it's ability to play and record a frequency sweep. I have a mic, and REW generates the sweep itself and records it in sync. I also think REW has the ability to 'eq' some to the audio being output (audio out from headphone jack or via USB to DAC), so I could theoretically do a little crude tweaking for testing. |
@fthompson251 I think you're right. I'm going to try just shifting everything backwards (towards the front wall) and starting there just to hear the difference/comparison. Always finding doing one extreme to the other with some things really helps you know at least the boundaries of things.
|
@elliottbnewcombjr I had uploaded an image to Flickr online, and gone thru the process you mentioned but for some reason when I hit "post response", I immediately get a warning screen "you are currently being blocked". I need to figure out the work around or better hosting site online (maybe dropbox?). |
@erik_squires and @fthompson251 and @elliottbnewcombjr |
@erik_squires I’m on your side man! You were 100% right, and dead on!!!!! Maybe you’re just ahead of your time and they are behind the curve? 😆 I think the actual biggest issue is his ceiling: the greatest expanse with NOTHING on it. His front wall doesn’t even have the equipment on it: it’s just bare, so I am going to start with that wall in general, first. |
@yoyoyaya I was almost thinking the same thing! Like, I wish I had and played the guitar, and could play a tune in the space, then play the same song thru the sound system and illustrate how much is "one generation of echo/reverb sound", and when the other is COMPOUNDED echo/reverb!! |
@yoyoyaya HA!!! Bigger is not always better!!! It's funny his space is over sized and empty, and my space is VERY small and VERY not symmetrical. |
@mijostyn The room is just so large, in a VERY large full size basement (it's effectively the nicely finished region of the whole basement with the basic 'foundation walls' as the boundaries, (listening area = 34'L x 24'W 10'H) with the other areas of the basement as unfinished and even open-wall-stud framing mainly. So to my ears and measuring, the Legacy speakers never really "pressurize" the room/basement. So lucky for him, he could always add subwoofers if really needed--but I think for his room/system the biggest boom (see what I did there) would be from dealing with the "empty chamber syndrome" effect. |
@erik_squires ~alan |
@mijostyn I agree with you. To me, his space needs 2 subwoofers (at least at this point it sounds like they do). Frequency tests show 130hz and lower just drops like a stone. Example : 1000hz is at -24db, and 80hz is at -44db at the nominal listening levels. I need to be careful though, father is VERY sensitive to bass and can be irritated instantly if he thinks/feels like it's 'boomy' or loud. I have heard a ton of systems with extremely articulate and impactful bass-you hear the detailed pluck or hit of bass, but you also feel it's impact and weight. With his system currently, it's just mainly the audible portion of the note/pluck/hit. |
@erik_squires Ya just wanna jinx things, don'tcha?!?! 🤣
|
I am sure you've all seen John's video series on dealing with his rooms, but these (there are 2 or 3?) are exactly what @erik_squires has been helping me with.
|
@erik_squires "Also worth noting that studies have shown that having meetings in highly reflective rooms is literally exhausting." Yup, I think we have all experienced that first hand in bars and restaurants, and theaters. That's why when my father said "I don't like listening to music above "X" setting----I don't need to listen loud---it's just too aggravating", but I thought 'man I can barely really hear it, and for sure can't FEEL music?!!?', then checked on the DB meter and it was at 64+ DB, I knew it was the room acoustics.
|
@erik_squires 🤣🐴🐐🐘🦏!!!! |
@erik_squires great insights again. I was just doing reading up on the specific frequencies and energy/directionality. I have been diving into that AM Acoustics web site as well, which has been PERFECT for this exact exercise: everything I am even roughly measuring and hearing, it is show as well. It mathematically predicts the RT60 in sync to what I measured, and it is also telling me the exact same higher energy frequencies with specific notes to test. |
@erik_squires Agree on all points. I'll send you a message on a couple details, and a sketch of the room and dimensions, so you specifically have a better idea.
|
Here is the room "treated" sort of over the top with utilizing what we have on hand, and making the largest change to hear/measure what is improved/worsened. From the RT60 measurements, you can see that we dramatically reduced the echo/ringing from over 700ms to just around 500ms, which some state is around average/acceptable in most contexts.
|
@audiom3 Oh that is awesome to hear!! I -LOVE- my Studio HDs in my small living room Home Theater 2.5 channel set up. I had Epos ES12s for awhile, which were "nice", but man the upgrade to the Studios was DRAMATIC!!! I think with my fathers system, his speakers are in an enormous cavern, and there is a lot of reverb and ringing that are masking a fair amount of bas, (as noted and instructed by @erik_squires ) For him, the lack of bass is perfectly fine (he doesn't hear it that way), but for me......if I were playing Sabotage....YOU BETTER BE BRINGING THAT BASS!!!!!!!
Out of curiousity @audiom3 have you ever used REW and would you be able/willing to do an in room measurement? I'd just like to see the difference in the bass response and levels comparatively. |