IMO you're asking for a lot at $2500. Subs are the obvious choice, but if that's not your bag these Nola Vipers might be a good choice. Bass down to 28 Hz and mids and tweets are dipoles like the Maggies that may appeal to you from an imaging perspective. At $3500 they're a bit over your price, but as I said you're asking for a lot, and these were originally $8000.
https://www.usaudiomart.com/details/649497865-nola-viper-ii-plus/
https://www.usaudiomart.com/details/649497865-nola-viper-ii-plus/