I installed the SL recently (on a VPI Prime) I really enjoy it. On the gain issue, I would be looking to see what your phono stage provides for gain and loading options. On a EAR 834p (with fixed settings for gain and 400ohm loading) and a Sutherland KC Vibe (60 db gain) the SL was a bit lower volume. I switched to a Manley Chinook SE with 65 db gain, loaded it at 800 ohms, and it sounds much better.
VTA is critical for the SL, and the MMF can be a bit more difficult to set VTA, so keep that in mind. My Ortofon 2M black and 2M blue were a bit less fussy about VTA.
So without knowing your phono stage and it’s gain settings, I would consider the SH as well. I have an Ortofon Bronze 2M I have not yet set up, and it is supposed to be warmer than the Black and closer to the Hana SL.
I don’t think the E series has quite the detail of the S series.
VTA is critical for the SL, and the MMF can be a bit more difficult to set VTA, so keep that in mind. My Ortofon 2M black and 2M blue were a bit less fussy about VTA.
So without knowing your phono stage and it’s gain settings, I would consider the SH as well. I have an Ortofon Bronze 2M I have not yet set up, and it is supposed to be warmer than the Black and closer to the Hana SL.
I don’t think the E series has quite the detail of the S series.