Greatest Rock Drummers


Given the subject line many names come to mind such as  Ginger Baker, Keith Moon, Phil Collins and Carl Palmer but, is Neil Peart the greatest rock drummer of all time?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YSToKcbWz1k
falconquest

Showing 5 responses by gpgr4blu

Ringo was the first rock drummer who turned the skins into a musical instrument. No one else would have come up with the concept of placing towels on the drums to get a soft muffled sound on Come Together. Listen to the perfect fills in Day In The Life. Listen to the very spare drumming on Penny Lane. Paul was a very good (but not the best) bassist, John was an average, if that, musician. George a reasonably good but not great guitarist. But they were among the best stylists on their respective instruments in rock history.
When I listen to music, I don’t want to listen to anyone’s technical chops. I want all musicians to serve the song---the musical destination of the imagination and the heart. When that requires technical skill--less than 20 percent of the time-- only then do I want to "hear" technical skill .
Note--Jim Keltner, Levon Helm and the like understood that.
Although I was a Who fan--Keith was often too predictable and created drum space for himself in songs whether the song called for excessive drumming or not. On the other hand, he was a very impactful and spectacular drummer on others (e.g. Baba O’Riley).
Ringo was simply virtually always tasteful and tuneful and often quite innovative.
Rock drummer who overplayed the most--Keith Moon
But, then again--Baba O'Riley--sublime drumming 
bdp24
Very nice summation of the distinction between drummers and musicians. Jim Gordon, Jim Keltner and Steve Gadd---all are musicians--very aware of how to play on a team to make the song the best it can be. They often had to sublimate their "I am a great drummer and let me show you" egos to do that. Ringo in his work with the Beatles was also a brilliant musician. I don’t believe he was as technically proficient as the others above--but it never mattered.