@tony1954. You might have to build whatever you want. Set your design parameters then solve them one by one. Mine were that the gadget be light, not expensive, functional and elegant. I have achieved all of them to varying degrees. Some were even exceeded. Like I said, you might have to create it yourself. Good luck.
Flatscreen between speakers
Has anyone found a solution to cancel or at least improve the acoustic glare caused by a flatscreen tv on the wall behind the speakers? I don’t have a dedicated room and have to share the room with my home theater setup. I have thought of using an appropriate curtain and treat the tv as if it was a window. I am also considering light 3D printed panels that I can temporarily hung when listening to music and take down when watching TV with the wife.
I tried hanging a couple of thick towels on it to see if there would be any improvement and the answer is yes. The center image is more solid and a little deeper. Nothing drastic but if I could squeeze anything positive, why not. Please let me know if you have confronted this issue in the past and whether you were able to solve it. Thanks.
- ...
- 141 posts total
Had a look at your setup and your solution with hanging a panel on the TV seems to be a more practical (and less expensive) solution. If I make it so it can either hang the panel on a French cleat situated above the TV when I am using the TV, or hang it on the TV itself when listening to music, then It should be the best of both worlds. |
I had this exact problem for years (dual use hifi and home theatre) and it can be overcome without room treatment or tv covers. Proper speaker positioning. I use Ron’s LOTS method - he has a video on YouTube. Once dialed in the difference between an open and holographic soundstage and something bland was as little as 1cm in positioning. Funny thing, I once got my speakers setup perfectly, then 6 months later upgraded the tv from a 55” curved to a 65” flat panel. This single change was enough to destroy all that work and the glorious soundstage I had. But it shows how critical the speaker positioning was to overcoming the centre reflection issue. I also had a tv cover custom sown and tried it after optimising with the LOTS method. It actually made things worse, because the positioning had already been done to account for the tv reflection. That’s also why changing to a different tv size had such an effect. |
I thought about how to incorporate a screen between my Apogee Divas. A projection screen with a retractable screen allows me to take the screen out of the way when doing serious listening. The pain of installing a projector and screen was impractical. Acoustic treatments you have to move in and out of use is a nuisance Eighteen months ago I discovered AWOL. It employs a 120 inch screen that sits anywhere behind the speakers, comes in different sizes, and it uses a short-throw laser projector that sits maybe 15 inches away from the screen on a slate base. The screen height is adjustable and is automatic, opening or closing in 30-40 seconds. It has a great 4k image, and the sound plays through your audio set-up. This gives me the option for what experience I want to have easily. Look on-line for AWOL. One of the best additions to my system, which had been purely audiophile for 46 years. HUGE wow factor for guests, too! |
@classicalpiano. That’s really cool. It’s called short throw projector. I learned something new today. That would have been my first choice if I didn’t already own a very good flat screen TV (maybe my last now). Thanks for sharing with us. |
- 141 posts total