Elrod Statement Gold PC compared to old Statement


I wholeheartedly agree with comments made on Audiogon that bestow many superlatives on the new Elrod Statement Gold PCs. I love how they transformed and elevated my system. They are phenomenal.

I have auditioned 2 Golds for the past 5 weeks and would like to share my observations based on an extensive comparison between fully burnt-in Statement Golds and the regular (old) Elrod Statement power cords.

All comparisons were done in my current primary system consisting of Maxx2, Boulder 2060 amp, APL Hi-Fi NWO-3.0SE CD player connected directly to the amp, Pure Power 2000 AC re-generator, Kubala-Sosna Elation interconnects and speaker cables, all Elrod Statement PCs, Critical Mass Systems Platinum* QXK and Grand Master platforms, dedicated AC lines, and dedicated Rives level 2 listening room which was featured (along with 2 other Rives rooms) in the October 2008 issue of Home Entertainment.

First, I must confess that I really liked the old Statement PCs. The more I added, the happier I became. There was a cumulative effect in the sonic enhancement. I ended up with 7 Statements in my previous primary system (Jadis JA80 driving Watt/Puppies, Conrad-Johnson Premier 350 driving the Wilson WHOW sub woofer, Sound Application RLS and Reference Linestage AC conditioners, Grand Master platforms, Kubala-Sosna Emotion ICs and SCs).

My current primary system requires only 3 power cords. As with my experience with the old Statements, there is a wonderful cumulative effect. Adding the second Gold to the system enhanced the sonics even more. I'll cut to the chase: I purchased the 2 Statement Gold PCs that I was auditioning and ordered a third one to complete my PC upgrade. This was a no-brainer!

The improvements over the old Statements are huge!! The Golds outperformed them in every parameter that came to mind: The bass is tighter, more controlled, more impactful and better defined. The highs are more open, cleaner, purer, and more sparkling. The decays are stronger, perceptibly longer, and are more transparent. There is greater resolution with more nuance and delicacy. Better macro and micro dynamics. Transients are faster and cleaner, with better defined peaks....more real. Images are more focused, more solid and stable. Separation between instruments is improved, the space between instruments is much cleaner/quieter, and there is more dynamic interaction between instruments. The clarity and transparency in the depth dimension of the sound stage creates a greater 3-D effect. More importantly, there is a greater organic wholeness to the sonic presentation that integrates the instruments into a coherent whole and reproduces the space of the recording venue. Overall, the presentation is smoother, more relaxed, natural, more real and involving.

Congratulations to David Elrod, the man behind this remarkable advancement in power cord design. A true gentleman and a creative and effective designer in high-end audio.

In all these tests, everything except the power cords remained the same. So, how can a power cord, which does not carry the audio signal, affect the resolution of so many sonic qualities in such a profound way? Among other things, the Gold PC lowers the noise floor level significantly....even lower than the already low noise floor in the old Statement. That allows the resolving capacity inherent in the CD player, amp, speakers, and signal carrying cables to be uncovered and perceived more easily. This is not unlike with video signals where the reduction of "snow" and other video noise can improve a whole range of visual parameters.

This outstanding low noise floor for the Statement Gold was evident throughout my audition. Initially, I compared the Gold with the Old on one component at a time. To minimize unsuspecting variables that may result from cable changes, I used the A/B/A testing pattern: I started with 3 Olds in the system, observed the sonic changes when the amp PC was changed to a Gold, then confirmed my observations by going back to 3 Olds. I repeated this process for the CD player and the AC re-generator. In each of these sessions, the more expensive Gold outperformed the old Statement. In my system, to my ears/brain/heart, it was not even close. At more than twice the cost, that should be expected. However, at its price point, the old Statement is a superb PC.

To test the cumulative effect, I also auditioned the Golds on 2 components at a time: CD/amp, CD/re-generator, amp/re-generator. I wanted to see/hear if the sonic benefit is worth the added cost. In my system, the resounding answer is Yes!

Additional details about my testing protocol: For short term tests, after each cable change the system was played for about 30 minutes (to re-stabilize it) before critical listening. When a test cable was removed from my primary system, it was installed in my second system (in another room) in order to keep it "warmed-up" for the next test. Finally, the results of my short term tests were verified by long term listening.

I used 15 CD test tracks....all well-recorded to minimize recording and mastering anomalies. I'll now convey the results with 6 of those tracks to flesh out a few of my comments about the Gold with greater sonic specificity and give a taste of its sonic bliss.

Take for example, the first 2 minutes of track #1 on the CD titled "Master of Chinese Percussion" (LIM K2HD 033). When the drum is struck, I feel the powerful impact of the waveform hitting my chest; and I hear the mallet contact the drum membrane, the response of the membrane, the resulting musical waveform, the resonance of the drum's body, and the changes in the tautness of the membrane depending on how close to its boundary the drum was struck. All are distinct events, unfolding sequentially in real time...in a split second!....Startling realism in the time domain. With lessor PCs, these elements may not be so easily or clearly distinguished; and possibly be merged into one homogeneous "boom".

Listen to the high frequency notes on the first 2 minutes of track #11 on Fim Super Sound II (FIM XR24 067). With the Golds in the system, each and every one of these strikes on the triangles and xylophones is crystal clear with fast and cleanly defined transients. The decays are so transparent that you can hear the interaction between the decays of different notes as they create a symphony with their ethereal harmonic textures....Sublime realism in the frequency domain. With lessor PCs, some of those strikes are smeared enough to make you wince or cringe; and some of those decays may be weak and smeared enough to obscure that exquisite symphony.

The 3 orchestral test tracks I rely on the most are track #1 on each of the following 3 CDs: Holt's The Planets/ Zubin Mehta (JVCXR 0228-2), "This is K2 HD Sound" (FIM K2 HD 078), Fim Super Sound (FIM XR24 066). With the Golds, orchestral presentation is reproduced with exemplary resolution, focus, clarity, separation of instruments, and coherence to die for. Instruments float.....liberated in space. You feel the action of the air they propel. You experience the sonic waveform from even the "minor" instruments at the back of the sound stage. You not only hear the air around the instruments but also the air around the entire orchestra....One organic whole....pulsating with life. Yes....There is a sonic Nirvana!
puremusic

Showing 12 responses by puremusic

Robert, Based on my own experience, I agree with you about the superiority of the Elrod Gold Statement PC. Your commitment to your new venture is further endorsement of that superiority. Good luck!
John
Perrew, The Elrod Statement Gold made a significant across the board difference in each component and even a bigger difference when 2 Golds were used. That is why I'm going with an all Gold system.

In my system, there were some differences between components. Bass impact and definition were enhanced more when the Gold was on the Boulder amp than when it was on the other 2 components. Transient speed was improved more with the Gold on the Pure Power 2000 re-generator. And the combination of the Gold on the amp and the re-generator was dynamite; the combination improved dynamics further and brought more life to the system than when the Gold was on only one of these components. But such variations are probably system dependent.

Yes, I did compare the sonics between going directly to the wall and going through the re-generator. No comparison. Pure Power wins hands down. Read Brent Rainwater's comments about Pure Power on their website. I know he is a dealer (rainwateraudio.com) for Pure Power and I normally ignore such a high endorsement; but I found his comments to be right on.

Best Regards,
John
Bostonbean, I only heard the Gold and the old Statement, not the Silver. Have you compared the Silver with the Gold or the old version? The only person (besides the designer/manufacturer) that I know who has compared all three versions is Brent. He says the Silver is a big step up from the old Statement, and the Gold is a big step up from the Silver. That indirectly supports my conclusion that the Statement Gold is a HUGE improvement over the old Statement. Others have used more colorful language than mine. One Audiogon member, on another thread, said he was "totally blown away" with the Gold (relative to his previous PC).

Enjoy,
John
Perrew, Thank you for your kind comments. Yes, the NWO is connected to the Pure Power. I tested both the amp, and the CD player. Each, by a long shot, was best when connected to the Pure Power.

In my system, the old Statement did not smooth over the sound. Quite the opposite, it was resolving enough to produce harmonic richness in the frequency domain and liquidity and speed in the time domain. It achieved the desirable kind of smoothness by resolving the details instead of homogenizing them. But the Gold takes that to a much higher level as you can see from my descriptions in the review.

Enjoy,
John
I must commend you for the extensive testing with all the different combinations.
Testing all those combinations was very useful for making an informed buying decision. Since I have been happy with the old Statements, I wanted to know if the improvement was significant enough to do the upgrade. And, given the high cost of the Golds, can I get away with only one. I was so stunned with the big improvement brought about by the second Gold, it was game over for me. Also, because the 2 Golds were great on every combination of 2 components, I concluded that a 3rd Gold will advance my system another step or two. That decision was made easier by my experience of the cumulative effect with the old Statements.
Robert (Strapper211), Once your 7 Golds break-in, I hope you'll give us your sonic observations in your highly resolving system. I'm looking forward to receiving my last Gold that will complete my PC upgrade.
Enjoy,
John
An Update: My system requires only 3 power cords. At the time of my review of the Elrod Statement Golds, I had only two Golds. I left them on the Boulder 2060 amplifier and the APL Hi-Fi NWO-3.0SE CD player, with the old Elrod Statement on the Pure Power 2000 re-generator. In the review, I noted that adding the second Gold made a significant sonic improvement over what one Gold offered. Recently, I received the third Gold which I installed on the re-generator. Since my system was already sounding fabulous, I was not expecting an additional major improvement. However....

When I sat down for a critical listen with just 45 minutes of burn-in time, I was stunned with amazement. Out-of-the-box, the third Gold made at least as big of an improvement as the first two Golds COMBINED. The third Gold further improved all the sonic parameters discussed in the review: better dynamics and greater realism; faster and cleaner transients; greater clarity and articulation; purer tone and better 3-D effect; better ambiance; etc.

What would account for such a huge enhancement? The first thought that came to mind was: The third Gold went on the re-generator which feeds both the amplifier and the CD player. Therefore, it improved both components at once. Whereas, the first 2 Golds each were linked to only one component. On second thought, I don't think that accounts for the entire improvement because of the results of the various combinations I tested during the review process. I had tried re-generator/Gold plus amplifier/Gold plus CD player/old Statement, as well as re-generator/Gold plus amplifier/old Statement plus CD player/Gold. To the best of my recollection, neither combination gave me anything near what I am getting now. Another factor that would help explain the huge addition by the third Gold could be better synergy between the three Golds. Perhaps, Robert (Strapper211) can comment on his experience of adding additional Golds to his system.
Hi Strapper211 and Simontju, I've been dealing with a project deadline, so I'm a little late in responding to your posts. Thanks for sharing your experience with the cumulative effect of adding more Gold Statements. Strapper211, you mention the enhanced effect when a Gold feeds a Gold. I totally agree with you. During the review process, when I was testing the two Golds in different configurations, I also observed that when a Gold fed a Gold the sonics were muchly improved over the option when the 2 Golds were on the amp and CD player (and the old Statement was on the re-generator).
John
REVIEW UPDATE: As noted before, out-of-the-box, the third Elrod Statement Gold power cord made a huge sonic improvement in my system. Now, after almost 400 hours of burn-in on the third Gold, I had another critical listening session, and the results are staggering. All the parameters I raved about in my review of the first two Golds have reached a new level of sonic excellence. There is now a phenomenal clarity, transparency and cleanliness that is evident in the rich and pure harmonic texture, in the life-like transients, delicate decays, natural sounding ambiance, crystal clear imaging, and a glorious frequency spectrum, especially the highs. My oh my....The airy highs take my breath away. An already silent background is now even more silent which resulted in an apparent increase of resolution of subtle details. The third Gold also enhanced the overall refinement and delicacy, realism and dynamics, naturalness and coherence. And the 3-D imaging is simply stunning. Congratulations to David Elrod for his superb creation!
Bostonbean, Congratulations on your decision to buy 3 Gold Statements for your BAT REX and BAT CD player. Based on my experience with excellent synergy outcome with my 3 Golds, I think you are in for a delectable sonic treat. I look forward to your review. By the way, that was an excellent review of the Elrod Silver Signature speaker cables.
Simon, Congratulations on getting your third Gold Statement PC. Your first impressions coincide with mine. The break-in process will unfold many more delightful sonic surprises. Keep us posted.

John
Bostonbean, I can relate to your predicament upon your initial audition of the Gold Statements: "I just about wet myself it sounded so beatiful." You're in for even a greater treat as they break-in. I agree with Robert that "you haven't heard nothing yet". Perhaps, David Elrod should include a box of Depends with every Gold Statement sold.