2. digital
  3. 134727-10748

disc player upgrade bug: Esoteric vs EMM vs PS Audio

I upgraded my amp(s) last year (Benchmark), then got the BHK preamp which astounded me and made me think PS Audio is keeping it real. Both moves were down in price and glitz from what I owned but huge leaps forward in quality. So now, with over 2000 discs (CD and SACD) I'm thinking the source might be the next big improvement. I've got an Esoteric X-01 limited and a Cary 306 pro (for CD use mainly). They sound great but are old tech now, so I'm wondering......... does it get better - as we here all do!
I was thinking about an experienced K-01 or maybe an EMM piece as a possible upgrade, but the PS Audio DAC and transport look very promising. Esoteric and their transport are amazing, I believe EMM uses their transport also but Ed works his magic in different ways. The PS Audio pieces use their own approach, and are very versatile - but - as of now - disc playing is my top concern, not streaming. PS Audio uses the Oppo transport though, and I've never heard anyone tout the robust durability of that transport . I suppose the end justifies the means, but durability is a big concern 'cause even the best gear if non functioning doesn't sound so good. Your thoughts or input please, but I've narrowed my choice to these 3 manufacturers so let's stay focused gang, mmm-kay?
24phun
stereo5's avatar
stereo5
6,385 posts
 
The Esoteric is a great spinner.  Doubt you will be able to get something better for less than 15K, and then again, how much better?  Law of diminishing returns definitely applies here.
jond's avatar
jond
5,798 posts
 
Are you able to audition at all? You have a couple of great disc players already and newer can be better but not always. Beyond that no specific recommendations but good luck!
24phun OP
56 posts
 
PS Audio gives a 30 day trial, so in your home, in your system.
The most meaningful sort of trial.
I already know how an Esoteric sounds in my system (or do I?) so a newer model can only sound better (fingers and eyes crossed, hoping).
bluewolf's avatar
bluewolf
66 posts
 
I had an EMM CDSD and replaced it with a Marantz sa-7s1 which I used as a transport and found superior.  I replaced the Marantz with an Esoteric K-03x again used as a transport. And this year I took a punt and bought a Jay's Audio CDT-3. This Chinese designed and made dedicated transport significantly outperformed the Esoteric in every SQ regard. A MK2 of the CDT-3 is coming out and I have placed an order for a second CDT-3 for my headphone system. The Jay's is available through Alvin of Vinshine Audio in Singapore and his service is second to none.
in_shore's avatar
in_shore
596 posts
 
BlueWolf , I would be happy and content with a great sounding CD player , In the near past I have owned EMM Labs , Esoteric and just recently PS Audio Direct Stream Memory Player and Direct Stream Dac senior now sold off, Have you listened to the CDP3? 
And finally ,.Love your system ! 
More to discover