Dipole Asymmetry


I am considering purchase of a pair of Martin Logan Summit X speakers. In my room, I am somewhat constrained for speaker placement. I could place the speakers about 3-4 feet off the front wall. My main concern is my audio rack would be placed directly behind the left speaker, while there would be nothing placed behind the right speaker. How detrimental would this asymmetry be on sound quality?
imgoodwithtools

Showing 3 responses by bdp24

If you can duplicate/imitate the scattering of the sound from the rack & components behind your left speaker with diffusion behind your right speaker, you may be all right. If not, timbral (tonality, coloration) and temporal (timing) differences between the left and right speaker may be audible.

Planars can use all the space behind them as possible, with 5’ a good compromise. 5’ allows for a 10 millisecond delay between the sound from the front of the panels and that from the rear reaching the listener’s ears (sound traveling about 1 ft./millisecond.). 10 milliseconds is about what it takes the brain to differentiate between two identical sounds reaching the ears from the same location (the speakers). 10ms results in the sound from the rear of the speakers being perceived by the brain as separate from the sound directly from their front. That reverse wave of dipoles is one of their characteristics dipole enthusiasts value in a speaker, as it (re?)creates depth and a large sound stage. Dipole users not wanting those characteristics are free to place absorption behind their speakers.

Some dipole owners lacking 5’ of space behind their speakers move the speakers out for serious listening, moving the speakers back when not listening.

Do you use grand-daddy literally or figuratively, cleeds? Magnepan has probably done more to popularize planar speakers than any other company, but the original Magneplanar Tympani T-I was not introduced until 1971, long after the original Quad ESL in 1957.

The Quad has absorptive pads on it's rear, installed by Peter Walker to make it more room friendly for the relatively small lounges of British houses. Maggies benefit greatly from space behind them (the more the better), but can be placed quite close to side walls with no sonic penalty.