DC Offset Issue in Don Sachs Preamp


I have a nice Don Sachs preamp.  It's making an incredibly loud popping sound on power off.  Obviously, it's always good to power preamps first then amps and reverse the order for power down. But, I'm still concerned about potential damage to my loudspeakers. 

Would this be do to a leaky coupling cap at the output stage?  Or not enough uF/capacitance to take out all the DC? 

I could email Don but I bought the amp used and I got the sense he may have retired. 

 

Any insight is very welcome. Thank you.

jbhiller

Showing 3 responses by lynn_olson

Don is still with us, contact him by email. My guess is the load resistor on the output of the cap has gone open, but I wouldn’t expect both channels to do that at the same time. Maybe something has gone wrong with the regulator. It would help to know what power amp you are using and how efficient your speakers are. (Khorns? Magnepans?)

The only way to be sure is look at the output with an oscilloscope and see how big that pulse is. You can get handheld Chinese models for about $200.

The final stage of the preamp is a cathode follower with an active pull-down, which is cap-coupled to the RCA output. The output is shunted by a large-value resistor to discharge the output cap. Don’t remember if there is a muting relay to mute the output during power-up or power-down. In the meantime:

1) ALWAYS power on the DS Preamp before activating your power amp. I’d give it a full minute to glow and stabilize operation before powering on the power amp. If any of the tubes do not light, do not use it. If the tubes make weird scratching or whirring noises, they need replacing.

2) When powering down, turn off the power amp FIRST, then power off the preamp about 10 seconds to a minute later. (You want the power amp fully discharged and providing no gain. No clicks should audible at all.)

I would definitely NOT power on or power off the full system on a common power outlet. If you are using a 12V relay system, you need to add logic to add the delays shown above.

This recommended power-on/power-off sequence applies to all mixed tube/transistor systems (with a few exceptions, noted below). The vast majority of tube preamps use cathode followers with the cathodes (the output node) at 100 to 150 volts DC. The coupling cap blocks the DC, but there can be transients when power goes on or off, as the cap charges or discharges.

The Raven preamp Don and I designed is an exception, because it is transformer coupled, not cap coupled, so on/off transients are far smaller (the transformer does not have a DC charge on it, and the preamp is internally balanced). The DS preamp you have is a superb preamp, but it is a more traditional design with cap coupling in the output section (there are no caps anywhere else, though).

All-transistor or all-tube systems can be switched on a common power switch, but it’s not good practice, since small DC transients can make it through the power amp, get amplified many times, and harm the loudspeaker (and startle the listener). The safest and least annoying approach is following the above sequence.

(Some manufacturers mitigate the problem with muting relays, but it is difficult to find relays that can switch 150 volts without developing contact deposits over time. A low voltage "dry circuit" which does not arc (typical input selecting relays or volume controls) is not a problem, but a high voltage relay that can tolerate a 150 volt arc is extremely difficult to work around. It makes no difference if a 120/240 volt light switch develops a little distortion, but the output of a preamp is one of the most critical nodes of the entire hifi system.)

Actually, posting these little "how-tos" on the forum is good for me, since the content can be added to the product manuals. I’m the one that writes them for Spatial.

Plenty of experience writing these things ... nine years at Tektronix in Oregon, followed by several years of editing Glass Audio and Vacuum Tube Valley. So it’s just keeping in practice.

Many of my designs are "thought experiments" to see if an idea works or not. In audio, you need to physically build something to hear what it actually sounds like. Before it’s built, it’s a sound you hear in your head, but it’s always a surprise to hear it for the first time. That’s been my experience since the Shadow Vector intro at the 1975 Chicago CES to hearing the Raven intro at the Seattle show in 2023.

(By the way, I am the owner of a DS preamp. Great design, and yes, I know what's inside.)