DAC Compatible with PS Audio SACD Transport


I have the PS Audio SACD transport on order. The ideal matching DAC to connect the PSA SACD transport is the just released PS Audio Direct Stream DAC II. But at USD8K, the price makes it seem like a bridge too far. Therefore I am looking for  another DAC that is compatible with the PSA SACD transport, for SACD playback via I2S. I am eyeing the Holo Audio Spring 3 KTE DAC as it is reported to be an excellent DAC and is substantially cheaper than the PSA DAC. 

Are there any other DACs that you can recommend? Or do you think I should bite the bullet and get the PSA SACD DAC?

I must admit to being tempted from time to time, as PSA releases regular DAC updates which essentially gets you a new DAC. But then sanity intrudes LOL. 

 

128x128dcpillai

Showing 3 responses by rar1

@dcpillai 

I also own the new PSA SACD Transport for almost a year now.  I have it paired with a PSA Gain Cell DAC, as I could not afford both the new Direct Stream and the Transport at the same time.  

To get all the SACD goodies that the PSA has built into its SACD Transport, you will need to use a current model PSA DAC.  Period, end of story.  

Does not matter if a competitor's DAC has an I2S input, it needs to be a PSA DAC.  I initially paired the Transport with a GUSTARD DAC, as it had I2S connections, but it doesn't matter.  Needs to be a PSA DAC.  With the Gustard, I had to connect to the transport separately for CD Redbook and SACD, so I had to use both I2S and something else. 

I purchased a used version of the Direct Stream from 9 years back.  GREAT DAC in its own right, but the new Transport does not support older PSA DACs.  End of life situation from a software perspective.  

PSA was great about it.  Paul worked with me and gave me credit for the used DAC that I could apply to the Gain Cell.   So net net I was ok and could use the Transport as intended.  Keep in mind though, the Direct Stream is in a different league than the Gain Cell.

Check with PSA directly and see if a used Direct stream would work out and what version it would need to be.  

Good luck,

Rich 

@smatsui & @dcpillai

 

My bad & my apologies if I gave out incorrect information. It was not done deliberately.

When I ordered the PSA transport, I never did any detailed research on the DAC side of things and thought that any DAC with I2S would work out fine and soon found out that that would not be the case. Didn’t know what PIN configurations were, let alone that they could be set.

Along the way I acquired an older Perfect Stream, which I thought was special and fantastic sounding, but would not work with the new Transport. The Gain Cell sounds ok and is no slouch, but it is not a Direct Stream. Also got to work with Paul directly to troubleshoot what was going on with my system, which was very cool.

Good luck with your new Transport, when you get it. It is excellent.

 

Rich

@dcpillai - Huge bummer.  Going back to our original conversation, is it possible the at the end of the day, you need a current production PSA DAC with the I2S configuration?  The issue you are having is the identical problem I had.  

And granted it is possible that there is a problem with the transport.  That would be the simple outcome.  

I would contact PSA and ask to work with Paul, he will work with you and figure it out.

Hope it works out for you.  Keep us posted.

 

Rich