I own both the Bricasti M5 and a Pi4 with the DigiOne Signature spdif output board. The M5 sounds much better as it should.
Commercial streamer (bricasti m5 spotlighted) vs Raspberry Pi 4 implementation.
Question to the digital gurus here:
Bricasti M5 ($1500) or their streaming board in DACs (upcharge $1000) are Raspberry Pi 4 implementations. So is the streamer built in the Boulder 866. I don't know on what platforms other streamers are built upon but I wouldn't be surprised if they are all Raspberry Pi 4s as well.
My question is: given the hardware is $50 that can be bought by anyone, what is it that these companies do additionally to justify the 20X surcharge. Better software? hardware? what can they do in the hardware?
Or is just fancy casing and an audiophile price tag?
Not trying to start a brouhaha, but am just curious.
Has anyone compared a home-made Raspberry Pi 4 streamer implementation to a commercial streamer (preferably known to be implemented on a Pi 4).
I own a Bricasti M12, and might just try one day to compare (by building a pi 4 and connecting it to USB input and comparing to ethernet input of the DAC), but hopefully someone has an answer already?
Bricasti M5 ($1500) or their streaming board in DACs (upcharge $1000) are Raspberry Pi 4 implementations. So is the streamer built in the Boulder 866. I don't know on what platforms other streamers are built upon but I wouldn't be surprised if they are all Raspberry Pi 4s as well.
My question is: given the hardware is $50 that can be bought by anyone, what is it that these companies do additionally to justify the 20X surcharge. Better software? hardware? what can they do in the hardware?
Or is just fancy casing and an audiophile price tag?
Not trying to start a brouhaha, but am just curious.
Has anyone compared a home-made Raspberry Pi 4 streamer implementation to a commercial streamer (preferably known to be implemented on a Pi 4).
I own a Bricasti M12, and might just try one day to compare (by building a pi 4 and connecting it to USB input and comparing to ethernet input of the DAC), but hopefully someone has an answer already?
9 responses Add your response
I just sold my M3 to try a few other cheaper DACs. If I re-purchase it I will get it with the Ethernet input. When I talked to Bricasti requesting info on getting the Ethernet input added, they suggested it would sound better than the M5. For now, I'm trying to decide to stick with a Pi based streamer or try a Lumin U1 Mini, Bricast M5, or maybe Sonore opticalRendu to see how they compare. Neither of the cheaper DACs I've purchased support Ethernet and one supports MQA over USB so I really need a streamer that supports multiple outputs, or just switchover to USB as that seems to support the most decoding options generally speaking with all of the different DACs I've been looking at. What is tempting is to try a new Pi4 with the DigiOne Signature spdif output board ( https://www.allo.com/sparky/digione-signature.html). This board looks pretty impressive and requires two power supplies: "It needs 2 PSUs, one for 5V/2A-3A (RPI) and a second power 5V to 6V 100mA. We do recommend the cleanest power supply possible (batteries, linear but even a good SMPS will work)" https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/review-measurements-of-allo-digione-signature-and-diyinhk-pro3z.4660/ gave it a clean bill of health. For ~$240 + power supplies you get what looks like a pretty impressive digital output. They also offer a USB based board too. For AES, these folks offer a Pi based output board http://www.pi2design.com/pi2aes.html. So many things to try... |
Trying a different tack. I just ordered the
sMS-200 Neo for $450 less 5% Discover kicker. Designed and built in Korea from the ground up. https://www.audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/sotm-sms-200-networked-audio-player-hardw... If I like it I'll probably grab a Farad PS. https://www.kempelektroniksshop.nl/accessories/power-supplies/farad-super3-power-supply.html |
I've been using a pi3 as a Roon endpoint for a few years with zero issues. I use the
https://www.hifiberry.com/shop/boards/hifiberry-dac-pro/ s/pdif output board along with an
iFi iPower supply. It sounds great but I have not compared it to anything expensive. |
Some use nano pi, some raspberry pi. I use a raspberry pi4 as a Roon bridge to my DAC through USB. I don't see the hardware making much of a difference in a streamer if their software implementation is proprietary it might affect the sound. I don't think it's well known on this site how many music streamers are based on these little pi boards. |