Coincident "Partial EclipseMK2or SL's Sonatina II?

These two speakers: Coincident's Partial Eclipse Mk2 and Silverline's Sonatina II have both been "upgraded" in the last year or so. I heard the original PE's and liked them but have not heard any of the Sonatina's. Both are about the same size,though,SL's are about$800 or more. I need some input from members who have owned either one or both of these "upgraded" models. I am concerned about the "exposed" sidefiring woofers on the PE's because I have a curious cat who may rub against them or nose them. I am also concerned that Silverlines seem to be always on the resale block....Nevertheless, Both models look like winners, but I want something that is going to be a keeper and long term. I like good bass and soundstaging and listen to classic rock, some "elevator" jazz, and big band. Soundstage magazine loved the Silverline's Sonatina II in a review from 2001. "Enjoy the Music" reviewed the PE's in October 2002 and liked them but seemed less enthusiastic about their overall performance. I like to hear from members whose opinions are often more reliable and honest than reviews. Regards, Jimbo