center channel speakers - Martin Logan vs Definitive Technology?


Howdy!

I have an extremely restrictive space in my cabinet to put a center channel speaker...6 inches tall and 22 wide. the height is a killer as almost all of the speakers I have found that I may want to use are 7 inches or taller.

And then I finally found the Revel c10 and it's exactly 1 inch too wide.. :(

Anyway, after extensive looking the two most likely candidates I have found that will work are:

Martin Logan Motion 8i
https://www.crutchfield.com/p_839MO8IB/MartinLogan-Motion-8i.html

Definitive Technology Mythos Seven
https://www.crutchfield.com/p_735MYTH7/Definitive-Technology-Mythos-Seven.html?tp=191&awcp=1t2&a...

Does anyone have any particular comments/impressions on either of these? I am going to go out and try them if I can find them in local stores but thought I would see if anyone has had any experience with them.

Thanks!

babyseaotter99

Showing 1 response by dlcockrum

If your processor has a "Phantom Center Channel" setting where it eliminates the center channel output and reprocesses that signal to the front left and right speakers you should try that and forego the center channel speaker entirely. If done properly by your processor, the soundscape cohesion and movement of sounds within the soundstage should be more natural and convincing just as it is with two-channel audio.

I went through a frustrating period for years trying expensive center channel speakers (first a Thiel MCS-1 and latter a Martin Logan Stage which was a great speaker) in my integrated 2-channel/HT setup and found that both ultimately added annoying frequency imbalance, and worse, the perceived height/aural location of the vocals was detached from the people on the screen. The brain will not be fooled on this area since it is intensely keyed to vocal localization.

My main speakers are tall and time aligned, so the improvement in realism was phenomenal. YMMV.

Suggest that you try this and see what you think.

Dave