Sometimes a CD doesn't agree with a certain drive. I don't know why, only that it happens to me on occasion. Try it on a different machine.
CD won't Rip
I have a 2010 Mac Mini thats works great but today I tried to rip the Living Stereo disc Saint Saens organ symphony by Munch/Boston symphony. I inserted the disc , it made a few fluttering noises and then ejected the disc. I ripped a few more discs and they worked fine. Is there a copywrite guard on this disc ??