Capacitor


Dear friends I am interested to upgrade my caps in the tube preamp from Audio theta tin foil 3uf200VDC to Miflex1uf 240VDC copper foil what are your thoughts will reducing the value to 1uf affect the bass and frequency response or should I go with a higher value than 3uf  
jasbirnandra

Showing 17 responses by rauliruegas

Dear @jasbirnandra  : 

https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/best-harmless-signatureless-speakers-capacitors/post?postid=1...

Wonderland ( thank's Pauly. ) caps are designed and manufactured on purpose for : tone control. I'm not who is saying that but what exist in internet sites and that's why you are " happy " with and now willing to buy other 18 wonderland caps and of course your " technical leader " is whom support you as pauly too.

Here a second fact coming from different source white papers where not only you but all the wonderland  caps users can confirm the other link. Please read all the pages an carefully the pages 4-5-6 and you will know why the wonderland caps makes everything but function as a capacitor to fulfil the electronics needs ! ! ! :

https://www.wima.de/wp-content/uploads/media/WIMA-Audio.pdf


This is what your electronics needs. What you buy is different and your privilege, the amp can't " choose " other that what you want:


https://www.mouser.com/WIMA/Passive-Components/Capacitors/Film-Capacitors/FKP-1-Series/_/N-9x371?P=1...


https://www.wima.de/de/produkte/impulskondensatoren/fkp-1/


Look at the charts and ask Jupiter or Odam manufacturer that gives you that information.



R.






Dear friends : I know that you don't like that " something " can disturb your staus-quo and certainly in no way is that my " arrogant " attitude.

The isse is that each thread in Agon is looking for thousands of gentlemans and not only by the ones that are posting.

Several of those viewers need to read and " listen " a different " song " and not always the same because each one of them have their own way of thinking and their common sense. They have the rigth to know alternatives and way important are the FACTS on each one of those alternatives and that's why I share  and I post all those information in the capacitor subject.

This is a public forum but any one of you can make your own closed blog and in this way no one can disturb you.

No one is owner of the capacitor " bible " as several of you think are and along that do not like that any one could post something that goes far away from your own " true ".


Btw, """"  to tell people what they hear, select and prefer is wrong...""""

@charles1dad  , please don't put words in my mouth:


https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/capacitor-2/post?postid=2233634#2233634

That was my answer to what you posted about.


Regards and enjoy the MUSIC NOT DISTORTIONS,
R.


Could be a good thing that all of you believers of " snake oil " can answer for your self this questions:

What looks any electronic/speaker designer when choose passive and active parts in his design? what is looking the designer for the audio item performance? ( obviously that at choosed price point. ).

He has several targets but at the end and due that his audio items are for sale he looks for an audio item design that over time been and be STABLE suffering the lower time degradation he can achieve at his price point.

Boutique resistors, capacitors, fuses and the like not only are not stable ( all of you confirm it when talk of " burn-in " ) but " could or can change or change the overall audio item stability ( as a fact exist a risk for the audio items. ) an its designed operation conditions.

Again, no audio system can improves what is in the recording what recording microphones pick-up, only can degrade the audio signal.

COMMON SENSE is the name of the game not our imperfect and limited aged ears capacities.


R.







Dear @jasbirnandra  @sns  : ""   how many hours of burn in will open the cap.""          "  Prior to burn in...."

Been a follower in the past I asked  the same questions thinking to go in the rigth path and deceited by my self ears and because I wanted that that been happening no matters what .
My ignorance levels in that specific regards was really high till I learned through technical oriented gentlemans that know " what is all about a capacitors ".
If you can read carefully the next information ( that does not comes by me. ) to know that are our ears the ones ( along other " things " ) that makes a self deceit because caps does not need burn-in:


""""""  Speaking from science, not superstition, I have yet to see -- or hear -- proof that film capacitors need to "settle in."

The reasons you use film capacitors are: (1) they more closely approximate the theoretical ideal of a capacitor than electrolytics -- especially in regard to frequency response; (2) they are far less inclined to change their characteristics than electrolytics; (3) if carefully manufactured, the foil and dialectric are evenly wound or layered.

Note point (3). If a capacitor is NOT evenly wound or layered, then the capacitance per unit area along the foil wrap will exhibit a higher statistical variance; and this variance will show up as a correspondingly higher statistical variance in the transfer of signal through the electric field, which can further yield an indistinctness in phase response on the "downside" of the capacitor.

So, here's the challenge: what, other than an accommodation factor in the listening, is the technical explanation for why a film capacitor would need a "settling" or "burn-in" time?


One thing is clear about breaking in speakers . . . the compliance of the spider, and often of the surround DOES change with use (they become more compliant). Old speakers that have been sitting around a long time often have unduly stiff spiders.

Styli usually sag a little after a break-in phase, and need to have the VTA recalibrated.

* * * * *

Take a box of styrofoam chips and shake it. After a while, the chips do indeed settle. The semi-random motion of the chips allows them to fill more spaces between each other, plus as they settle the lumped potential energy declines as the center of mass of the chips moves slightly down.

So . . . are there physical imperfections in the manufacture of capacitors which allow small amounts of internal movement in the capacitor during the so-called "break in" time, such that the capacitor arrives at a lower energy state?

In an ideal capacitor, nothing should move. 

 . . . has anyone measured the microphonic characteristics of capacitors said to settle in over time? Has anyone determined if there's a tiny change in temperature?  """"""


"  I'll be the odd man out. I have never seen any evidence that capacitors, particularly film capacitors, require a burn-in. If a film capacitor significantly changes after, say, 25-50 hours of use, I quickly unsolder it, toss it in the trash and replace it with a stable device.

Film capacitors are not cheese or wine.

What "burns in" is the human brain, and this is referred to in psychoacoustics and elsewhere by terms like "perceptual accommodation".  ""

"""  With the exception of electrolytic capacitors in DC power supplies, capacitors don't burn-in.  """

"""  Honestly, if a film capacitor needs any sort of "break-in", it's poorly constructed and should be avoided  """

https://www.head-fi.org/threads/capacitor-burn-in-how-long-does-it-really-take.442436/



Low QC with boutique caps is the real issue of that no-sense needs of " burn-in ".
Certainly not me but no one of you can prove it needs burn-in other than its low quality construction that makes that over 100-200+ hours of " play " its operation parameters changed ( this fact goes against the elctronics normal behavior and in speakers makes changes in the crossover frequency. ) when in any good engineered capacitor that does not happens.

So the boutique cap does not " improves " over time but the other way around: it just degraded through that time and it's this high degradation of the cap what we are listening through our imperfect and way limited ears.

In any audio system nothing can improve over time. The best that could happens in an ideal audio system is not degrade the audio signal we are listening but unfortunatelly this " ideal " audio system does not exist but in our imagination.


""  Does a capacitor improve sound quality?

A cap prevents the sound from deteriorating due to under-voltage, but doesn't actually improve the sound. It supports the amplifier by feeding it the power it needs for short bursts. So, while not improving sound quality directly, a cap does make it easier for the amp to perform its best. ""

A good cap makes that, a boutique cap can't do it.


Regards and enjoy the MUSIC NOT DISTORTIONS,
R.






The overall advantage with the Klark TekniK item or similar ones is that we have de control of that " tailored " kind of quality performance and we are not at out of control an at random like with the boutique combination caps.

In that regards there is nothing that can does the caps for we can have the control we are in the caps " hands ". Now,  our items in the audio systems  already came with caps ( that makes it's technical job. ) and  the eq. path is for fine tunning that audio room/system: advantages are to many to name it here but just " think about ".

R.
Technical Specifications Inputs Type Electronically balanced (pin 2 hot) Impedance 20 kΩ Maximum input level +22 dBu Outputs Type Electronically balanced (pin 2 hot) Minimum load impedance 600 Ω Source impedance <60 Ω Maximum output level +22 dBu into >2 kΩ Performance Frequency response ±0.5 dBu 20 Hz - 20 kHz relative to signal at 1 kHz EQ out ±0.5 dBu EQ in (flat) ±0.5 dBu Distortion (THD+N) < 0.003% @ 1 kHz +4 dBu Dynamic range >114 dB (20 Hz - 20 kHz unweighted, ±12 dB range) Overload indicator +20 dBu Gain control -∞ to +6 dBu Equalisation 30 Bands Centrefrequencies To BS EN ISO 266:1997 25 Hz-20 kHz, 1/3 octave tolerance ±5% Maximum boost/cut ±12 dB, ±6 dB High pass filter slope 12 dB/octave Low pass filter slope 12 dB/octave Notch filterattenuation >17 dB Notch filter response Q=32 Terminations Audio 3-pin XLR and 6-pin Phoenix-style Power 3-pin IEC Power Requirements Voltage 100 to 240 VAC, 50 to 60 Hz Consumption <60 W Dimensions Width 483 mm (19.0") Depth 228 mm (9.0") Height 133 mm (5.2") Weight Net 5.8 kg (12.8 lbs) Options Input and output balancing transforme.
Dear gentlemans : Seriously and in good shape. Next item is a trusty " best boutique cap, it's the boutique cap of the caps " to enhance any room system MUSIC enjoyment and with several advantages over any an all those caps and permits that you tailored the MUSIC natural color you want it and with very low added distortion levels.

It comes not from a new comer manufacturer but from an experienced one, with high engineering levels, excellent QC and the item has very high quality performance.

We can't go wrong with:


https://www.klarkteknik.com/product.html?modelCode=P0ACA

here its specs in page 6:

chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/viewer.html?pdfurl=https%3A%2F%2Fmediadl.musictribe.com%2Fmedia%2Fsys_master%2Fh6c%2Fhaf%2F8847686893598.pdf&clen=6221900&chunk=true


In the past I owned items coming from this manufacturer and I will buy again.


Have fun and be truly happy.


R.


@audioman58  I had for 3-4 months a Coda amplifier and are really good, unfortunatelly a manufacturer with low profile but very good one.


Dear @sns  and gentlemans : ""  W/K/V no coloration, only accurate. So, everyone using colored boutique caps has defective equipment which requires colored, distorted boutique caps to sound natural.  ""

Your words not mine. Tha's not the capacitor issue.

""   you have the best ears, equipment and caps  ""

Never posted that in this or other threads any where.

The boutique cap subject is similar to the boutique fuse one where the audiophiles convinced  by ( like me. I used those fuses too. ) use it as tone control/equalizers.
So it's totally normal that all internet " oficial " caps wider comparisons speak not of the true work for what caps were " invented " when using in copupling/filter tasks ow whatever. Yes, no where does comparisons speak which caps make the best technical measured job but the other way around: only speak of differences in tone characteristics when a cap must be neutral doing its task.
Is even " crazy " to see speaker crossover with 4-5-6 different brand of caps ( in electronics that could be because is different down there. ).

Other " weird " fact is that all the boutique caps need from 50 to over 250 hours to settle down ( to shine. ) and the " weird " issue is that in the site of manufacturers do not exist a simple chart/diagram how the cap measures after 5 hours and the huge differences after 100 hours. ! ! ?

Yes, I know that that makes sense to you because you already " experienced " that " fact ". No, W/K/V does not needs 100 hours to " shine ".

""  This thread is about why and what we like our chosen caps..""

Well my understand according the OP thread statement is that he was looking for an upgrade through cap changes.

Almost all of you just do not likes and feel " unconfortable " when some one as me post a totally different well founded " information " that was is your point of view. Yes, I know I'm not welcomed and is ok with me.

Regards and enjoy the MUSIC NOT DISTORTIONS,
R.



 
Dear @sns  : Seems to me that you read my posts but " not  really read it.

You posted :

   "" it had no definable character. ""  and I told you:


""  Why should has that " character " a well engineering passive device? Let that for the active devices in electronics.  ""

and told you that W/K/V caps are: neutral/natural. But still you don't give a specific answer to that question and is critical for this dialogue.

Normally electronic manufacturers are not looking for passive parts with that " character/coloration " ( that are, like it or not: distortions.  ) but for neutral/natural and accurate devices. I participated in the design/manufacture of my custom made SS phonolinepreamp where all parts ( active/passive ) were not only measured through a friend of my friend in an University but listened by us and beta audiophiles.

Accuracy is the name of the game in electronic designs/manufacture. Accuracy does not means analithic but that choosed passive/active devices/parts in the design be accurate to defined specs losting and adding the less to the audio signal that pass through it.
If what they choosed are non-accurated against they targets then will try to find out what it is or choose for the best trade-offs for their designs.

Yes, the electronic final unit has its own character/signature due to all the several variables in the different stages and that the parts/devices are not " perfect " are not 100% accurated.

Those sound characteristics that you look for as transparency and resolution ( between others. ) does not comes from colored passive parts or passive parts that develops by it self any kind of distortions but from whole accurated parts in the overall audio system and  not by a passive part as you try  to impply/explain.

Btw, MUSIC is accurated that's why exist tone or semi-tones  and the like ina pentagram. If in a group/band/orchestra one or more players are out of tone you can be sure you will listen it and that is not a coloration but a distortion against the whole orchestra: is out of tone, tone is accuracy.

Fundamental notes and harmonics are developed with accuracy that you can't change it. It's the natural flavor color of the MUSIC that's what we listen at a live event.


"" I don’t know which Wima models you tested and if were the same model I posted. ""

Could you share which W caps tested?


In your posted next statements I can see part of your targets that could explain your bias/attitude on the subject:


"*"* I want my caps to have a sound signature..........." and definite sound signature with various boutique caps *"



You just posted this:

"  "" it would be nice to see proof for the objective assertions. ""

Well 99% of SS electronics designs use W/K/V and around 80% of tubes does it from Lamm to other humble units.

Additional to that you can read again the technical/measures information that comes in that link.
Probably in your electronics comes some W devices.

Btw, I can see in your system your analog rig with the Sp-10 very good TT, a prety decent Jelco tonearm  and what looks as a cartridge from the 103 family. At least in that analog rig and with all respect to you high resolution/transparency or other MUSIC characteristics can't exist but at very low quality levels. Additional could be important to you know which is your phono stage RIAA eq. deviation that maybe could be around 0.5db to over 1db and the swing of the RIAA deviation on those levels is totally unaccurated.


"""  """" Quality should not be understood simply as judgmental term, rather it should be understood in regard to audio as a term to explain the qualities of the sound we are hearing """"


So you are talking of your room/audio system and I have some far away " idea " how could performs when the audio signal not only pass through tubes but a lot of transformers, this audio signal go a cross " miles " of a tortuose path, maybe I'm wrong and is transparent, with high resolution and with the natural color of MUSIC.


" one is singularly in possession of some audio truth. "

I'm in possesion not of an audio ruth, only shared  some kind of facts and information in the cap subject.



This is what other gentleman posted and that I take as if I did it:


""  Good caps do not add colorations - they show you the limitations of your system through a magnifying glass  ""


R.













Dear @sns : " I’m generally skeptical when anyone claims objective superiority for any particular piece of audio equipment or part. So, Raul claims Wima is the most superior cap for any use. ..................... I want my caps to have a sound signature, ......... As far as other parameters of sound quality, such as transparency, resolution, more should be better. "

Wima, Kemet and Vishay manufacture a wide range of cap models for different kind of applications. It’s not that one model is for all, at least was not my intention if I posted that. I think I posted for : electronics/speakers.

Now, the specific models on each brand that I posted were selected after tested several other models in each brand even caps that in specific was not for audio but my technical level to know that for sure is to low.

Wima, Kemet and Vishay models posted has a sound signature: neutral/natural. There are not much differences in between those models.

You mentioned: " transparency and resolution... " and I said that the humble caps are: neutral/natural.

You posted: "" it had no definable character. "" Why should has that " character " a well engineering passive device? Let that for the active devices in electronics.
Active devices have its own " problems " as to add passive parts own " problems " in the manufacture electronic units. Passive parts must be not a source of distortions/colorations by it self and if the designer is looking for those " colorations/distortions " for the unit performs in adequate way then exist a severe problem in his design.

IMHO those sound characteristics belongs to the audio system designs quality performance ( including the manufacturers QC in the building its designs. ) and how that system handled both frequency extremes specially the bass range where in a home system MUSIC belongs. No, not belong to the mid range.

I don’t know which Wima models you tested and if were the same model I posted. ( same for jbhiller, grannyrings and others. ).

Please let me talk of : transparency, resolution and system noise floor where system transparency and high resolution can’t exist if the system noise floor is really really low ( that almost disappears. ).
Any system will receive high benefits ( noise floor levels ) when the owner took as a target to set up the system any kind developed distortions at MINIMUM at each link of the system chain.

I will share my first hand experiences about, this is only an example:

I own a custom made SS Phonolinepream that by design is fully balanced input to output, pure class A, fully dual mono, discrete design, non-feedback and several other very good characteristics.

Well, years ago I bought two stereo SPL pots/attenuators ( Elma mechanism. ) that were in a box and never opened/used.

My unit comes with two Elma true hole Vishay resistors and I was really happy with.
Two years ( I think. ) ago I remember I own those pots that came with SMD resistors and decided to change instead the originals and I did it and with the whole system on the first " sound " ( with out playing nothing, no signal through. ) I listened was a " dead silence " as I never experienced ( normally I listened by nigth where the room noise floor is lower than in the afternoon. ): the system noise floor gone lower with that simple change.

What happened when put I the first LP recording and gone to my seat position?; I was totally disappointed because both frequency extremes " gone ", even I listened as the normal SPL where the potswere and that I did not change with the new pots and for me the SPL gone down and I followed my listening session nad measured the SPL and for my surprise still the same. My impression over all that session did not changed.

At the middle of next night session took in count what was happening because all the MUSIC was THERE but with way lower distortions and with higher system resolution than before.

Yes, the SMD resistors made it.

That same experience I had and have with my cap " voyage/adventure " and I posted in my cap thread.

Those kind of experiences ar nothing less than overwhelming, outstanding and makes a real difference in any well designed system, no doubt about.

Through the humble caps sessions I was not totally sure if that noise floor goes down and I return to the boutiques caps and guess what : noise floor goes up and resolution/transparency gone down !.

This is not something that only experienced by me but for other gentlemans too.

Well I have to with my family. Have a good week end and find out if you own a high resolution system and if you are satisfied with that resolution levels.

Yes, we own different electronic technology items but our priorities seems to me is the same: MUSIC and its rigth reproduction or near it.


Yes, my system has very high resolution and ceratinly it's not 2D or lifeless but the other way around. When you are listen to it you don't want to stop you don't want to stop all the feelings and emotions that what you are listening is wake up in you and that only MUSIC can do it.

R.











Dear @jbhiller  : ""  I do believe I hear better signal through two of the Vcap lines and others..""

Agree with you because I was seated rigth " there " and was what I like it  even " love " it too.
I was not " stupid " to spend thousands of dollar ( through several years. ) in almost all but the Jupiter caps if I was not satisfied with.
So I understand you perfectly as to the other gentlemans.

Certainly I'm not against you or any one else but only in favor of MUSIC that at the end is what really matters.


Btw,  """  tell me I am not hearing what I have heard, that I have wasted my money, or that I have behavioral health problems, ................................. but your "expert knowledge".. """

Pauly I never posted that kind of words or statement to you or any one else.

The " problem " is that exist on almost all of you a " misunderstood " of what is the main target on the overall capacitor subject.

Again, because I already posted in this thread at least 2 times,: WHAT IT MATTERS IS NOT WHAT I LIKE IT ( or any one else. ) THE MORE BUT WHAT A CAPACITOR SHOULD DOES. WHY EXIST A CAPACITOR.

So the issue are not us but the capacitor true/real operation task with foundation in evidence/facts/measures.

All the boutique caps are colored and its colorations is what makes us happy and this reality is not under discussion but fact is that caps as Wima/Kemet/Vishay with evidences performs as the caps should performs: signatureless  - lower colorations and we are not accustomed to. That's all and that explain why the OP already decided to buy what goes with his priorities.

Is he wrong? no it's not it's what he like it. Simple.

Pauly: " expert knowledge ", here you are wrong because I'm only starting to learn about caps as Wima and the like as a fact thank's to this thread I learned when I found out that first link I posted with technical information and measures that by coincidence ( I was unware of that information before this thread. ) confirm my new experiences about what those " humble " caps can shows.

R...






Dear @jbhiller  : ""  Wima  are fine caps that do a decent job and meet spec. But they do not come close to things like VCap.  ""

A just two years ago my point of view was way worst against Wima that your nice words about.

Maybe the differences in what we think in the caps specific subject could be that I think you have several years more than me to be exposed to tube electronics and I left tubes ( I was with for around 10 years. ) years ago for full SS electronics when I " discovered " SS technology to sound reproduction.

My first hand experiences and even today experiences listening to other systems with tube electronics still tell me that tubes are more colored items than today SS units. I can say more colored and noisy.  

Could be that those colored and noisy tubes performance don't let to we can listen all the real Wima quality level performance and that those tube characteristics could hide the real quality performance of the boutique caps.

When we are accustomed to some kind of colorations ( coming from tube or SS devices. ) what we want it is more of the same with " higher quality "..

Due that Wima/Kemet/Vishay are low coloration caps just does not hide the weaks in electronic/speaker designs. Wima naked those colored units, so we don't like it what we are listening with the Wimas and prefer the boutique ones.

Btw, between others I used the Teflon V-caps you are using and can't does what the Wima /Kemet/Vishay does.

R.




Dear @charles1dad : "" So if a listener actually compared the Duelund CAST, VH ODAM and Wima capacitors and having heard them (In his components/audio system) found the Wima the least impressive he is wrong and misguided?

Wima is the only correct choice ? The other two capacitors are merely flawed, inferior, colored and distorted? It is totally irrelevant if the listener prefers the sound quality of the CAST or ODAM ? This preference is simply borne out of ignorance and lack of understanding? ...""

Answer to each one questions: NO, and NO ! but the colored and " flawed ".

Now, I experienced/first hands for years the " boutique " caps in my system and other systems and I " like " it what I was listened. Wima? no way that I thougth on them was a forbidden cap for me no matters what.

So: I was wrong? yes but the real issue is not about me or you or what I like or you like it or any one else.

The real subject is about caps and what they should do and what they must not do and the why’s it performs well or not. Tha’s why I share the first link in this thread that I was unaware of it when I started my caps thread looking for help trying to find out the: BEST NOISELESS SIGNATURELESS one, this is part of that thread title.

There I discovered WIMA/KEMET/VISHAY caps that was and is the answer for that cap thread title.

The discovery task was really hard for me because I was totally biased/married to boutique type capacitors. So I made efforts to be " unbiased " and started from " zero " with out my really big prejudices against Wima and the like.

I’m totally sure that with out that " unbiased " attitude I just can’t discovered what was in " front of me " for to many " follower " years audiophile attitude.

When I listened my first Wima through the crossover speakers what I listened I still have " present ": dullness sound with no " life ", my first thought was to forget about and return to the boutique ones but I decided to gave a few days not to the Wima caps but to my brain to " digest " that different sound I was experienced and thank's to that I started to learn what I was losting/missing with the Wima/Kemet/Vishay capacitors that existed in the boutique caps that I loved through many years and what I missed were its high COLORATIONS against the way lower colorations in the Wima cap.

R..




Dear @jasbirnandra  : This is the Vishay alternative to Wima and Kemet:

chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/viewer.html?pdfurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.vishay.com%2Fdocs%2F28173%2Fmkp383.pdf&clen=164592&chunk=true

R.
Dear @grannyring :  ""    what we have found that works for our ears and music. No need to argue. I am happy for Raul.  He has found what works for him and that is great...""

Well, one thing is that works for your ears and other way different that works too for MUSIC as comes in the recording. As in my thread you never posted and post true evidence/facts/measures for your " wonderful " caps that even in its manufacturer sites exist nothing that works as real foundation for your words.

Do you think that the Lamm owners are unhappy with their electronics? certainly not because in the Agon ads under preamps are around 200 units and no single Lamm.

Btw, in this overall cap subject is unimportant what we like it but what should be or must be:

THAT OUR ROOM/SYSTEM  PERFORMS AS NEARER TO THE RECORDING AS WE CAN ACHIEVE.

Obviously that you have a way different target. That's my main target and you know what: when you are near to achieve it not only you will like what you are listening but you will fall in love with because for the first time in your room/system you are truly listening to MUSIC not a colored/degraded presentation.

Of course that even that some day we can achieve that target we will stay still away from a Live MUSIC reference.

""  I am happy for Raul. "" come on. Other gentleman acuse me to be condescendent, I'm not  and I want to let you now that sincerely I'm sad for you but more for MUSIC reproduction in your room/system with that: "   works for our ears ..". 

Seems to me that unfortunated the real characteristics of MUSIC listen it at near field position are almost unknow for you or have a misunderstood about.

Anyway, my point is to help the OP ( as always. ) not if you agree or not. He has the rigth to read/know a different approach in favor of MUSIC.An approach that unfortunate goes against all of your opinions, that's unanimous .

Regards and enjoy the MUSIC NOT DISTORTIONS,
R.






Dear @charles1dad @grannyring and friends:

Could be that I look as a condensendent person and that I not only know but are superior in audio subjects to any one else.

Well, that kind of " look " is only that because I’m different and certainly always learning from any gentleman as you and even from audio rookies.

I remember all of you that as you I was entitled with the boutique capacitors and against Wima like ones. Even every single audio item I bougth in the last 30 years my first step with was change all the Wima caps for " better " caps that always sounded to me better in exactly the same way as all of you.

So please don’t have a misunderstood on me and what is behind my posts. In my capacitor thread is all explained and through that thread I DISCOVERED Wima/Kemet/Vishay JUNK capacitors. Yes was a total turn around in my audio life and happened in the best time with my room/system when is fine tunned better than ever.

Now, the capacitor subject is not an issue of " I like it " but is first than all understand what does and what does not a capacitor ( that’s why I share that link. ). It’s a engeneering subject and sooner or latter we need to understand it.

It’s not true that top electronics designers don’t choose " boutique " caps because $$$ or because the caps dimensions or because " are not open to learning ".
Far aaway from there, the competition at that high electronics levels makes that all those manufacturers look to give to the market THE BEST OF THE BEST and nothing less.

In my thread I linked electronics with a cost no object price: 80K+ for an amplifier or over 60K for a preamp ( CH is an example. ) where the circuit boards are full of Wima or Wima like caps everywhere. These designers has no problem design with expensive caps because the audiophiles are willing to buy the products coming from those top manufacturers.



https://lammindustries.com/pages/power-amplifiers-ml3/

do you know its very high prices? maybe no one here can afford it and guess what : WIMA and VISHAY Roderstein caps.

Here other example:

https://lammindustries.com/lamm-website/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/M2.2_inside.jpg


Problem with all of us audiophiles and MUSIC lovers is that in reality " we are not willing to learn " not even to read something that " moves the land " as earthwake.


As audiophiles some of us ( including me. ) are at the hunt of " boutique " items that can " improve " our systems and we go for the more expensive and we don’t use or name/post Wima because is " junk " and we can " lost " figure and credibility. Unfortunatelly we are just followers and I’m sorry to said it.

It’s totally " weird " ( for say the least . ) that it does not matters the electronic/speaker item each time we change caps for the " boutique " ones always sound the better and is a full improvement.

How can be that way and what could means? it could means that the items designs all are WRONG designed because with the cap changes we " improved "?

So what are doing all those designers when with those changes we are better that they. We have better know-how?. Certainly not.

What is happening about has no real sense and something is wrong down there.
It’s not as @grannyring posted: "" try Wima on your own folks """ but to make an effort to understand the subject facts not " I like it " because normally what we like it is wrong or could be wrong but just does not cares us but MUSIC is to valuable to stay " static " and degrading it each time with those caps, fuses, resistors and the like " boutique " parts.
Yes, I know that we love those " colorations/distortions " that does not came in the recording.

@jasbirnandra the caps you can use all over your electronics or speakers can be these ones that I use instead of Cu teflon Vcaps I was using:

https://www.wima.de/en/our-product-range/pulse-capacitors/fkp-1/

or and alternative in speakers crossovers due that has a wider uf range than the Wima and are very good too:

chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/viewer.html?pdfurl=https%3A%2F%2Fcontent.kemet.com%2Fdatasheets%2FKEM_F3118_R76H.pdf&clen=1380003

Ovbiously both with radial short leads.


R.



Dear @jasbirnandra and friends : Next are statements made it in this thread that similar to other statements made it in several threads ( including a thread I posted almost two years ago. ) on the capacitor issue: :

" Milflex are good, but not great. The VH Audio Odams sound better in every sonic way..."

"" more holographic image I suggest two cap brands.
- VH Audio Odams
- Duelund CAST CuSn - tinned copper version ""

""" New pre-amps, which incidentally will have the same or similar mediocre capacitors we are replacing in the Canary pre amps; meaning we’ll be back at square one looking to upgrade capacitors in our new pre amps. """

"""" the Duelund CAST Cu(Sn). This is the best sounding capacitor ever produced in my opinion. """"


""""" As I’ve said before in regard to them, they are worth every single penny charged for them. A superb sounding product """""

"""""" was immediately heard as an improvement ( Even though quite honestly the sound was very good with the stock Solens). Sound quality continued to improve as the CAST accumulated hours of break-in. """"""

""""""" It sounds like angels are in my room singing to me. Strings just hang in the air and the low level detail is almost overwhelming. """""""

"""""""" More open, improved bass and dynamics. """"""""

""""""""" And how are they on tonal balance, accentuate, soften or change any part of frequency spectrum? """""""""


With all respect to all of you. From where comes that differences in capacitor sounds when a good designed capacitor can’t develops/generate a sound by it self and certainly can’t improve the quality performance of good electronics designs or speaker crossovers.

When I posted my capacitor thread looking for help many of you posted about and I really appreciated your posts.

Well in those times I was not aware of the next link on capacitors,things are that I just found out today and could be truly interesting for some of us ( me included. ) this spot on capacitor article:



https://sound-au.com/articles/capacitors.htm



@jasbirnandra in the next link the last page of my thread. Please take your important time to read all that page that as the linked article is self explained:


https://forum.audiogon.com/discussions/best-harmless-signatureless-speakers-capacitors?page=4


in that thread I posted several links with measures, proved facts and true evidences on the whole capacitor main issue. One of those links was this one ( you need to paste all the link: the black/blue  that start at " chrome-extension........ ):


chrome-extension://efaidnbmnnnibpcajpcglclefindmkaj/viewer.html?pdfurl=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.vishay.com%2Fdocs%2F26033%2Fgentechinfofilm.pdf&clen=595770&chunk=true

Certainly it’s not at random that Wima, Kemet and Vishay are the world industry capacitor standard.
You can name any kind of industry: medical instruments, military, aerospace, automotive and almost everywhere but " high-end " audio and only are used those caps in specific areas but as me in the past no one ask why are used " there " and not the " boutique/sneak oil " " caps ".

I invested thousands of dollars learning through the boutique ( almost coming from every manufacturer ) caps and finally I learned through the standar caps that are the ones I use in electronics and crossovers.

Of course because my main MUSIC/sound target in my room/audio system is to be truer to the recording truer with what the recording microphones pick-up in its MUSIC source near field position.
This means that I try to mimic what I listen in a live event seated at near field position as the microphones are, yes I’m really far away to achieve it.


Regards and enjoy the MUSIC NOT DISTORTIONS,
R.