I have not reviewed the Aeris, but have reviewed the V, Valor, Whisper (various versions) Focus, Focus SE, all found at Dagogo.com
Legacy uses their large form factor, large midrange, methods in the Aeris. Imo, there would have to be some anomaly at work to draw such a conclusion, or if someone is a panel fan I can see them comparatively discussing the sweet spot as small in comparison.
I have heard Aeris several times at shows and it never had small sweet spot or poor off-axis sound. Roger Sanders' speakers are poor off-axis, and he lines up chairs like a runway in demos. Legacy places several chairs in a big square for listening. They are not afraid to have someone sit off-axis, and you can stand up around the Aeris and not have the sound collapse.
Now, Bill Dudleston prefers to cross the speakers before the listener, whereas I think that does unacceptable (to me) things to the soundstage and center image. I am not about to tell a man of his pedigree he's wrong, but I prefer a more traditional setup. If the reviewer was using the Legacy preferred placement, then that likely accounts for a lot of the description.
So, something as simple as positioning could be behind the different descriptions of such things.
As I have not used the Aeris in my home I will refrain from further comment. :)
Legacy uses their large form factor, large midrange, methods in the Aeris. Imo, there would have to be some anomaly at work to draw such a conclusion, or if someone is a panel fan I can see them comparatively discussing the sweet spot as small in comparison.
I have heard Aeris several times at shows and it never had small sweet spot or poor off-axis sound. Roger Sanders' speakers are poor off-axis, and he lines up chairs like a runway in demos. Legacy places several chairs in a big square for listening. They are not afraid to have someone sit off-axis, and you can stand up around the Aeris and not have the sound collapse.
Now, Bill Dudleston prefers to cross the speakers before the listener, whereas I think that does unacceptable (to me) things to the soundstage and center image. I am not about to tell a man of his pedigree he's wrong, but I prefer a more traditional setup. If the reviewer was using the Legacy preferred placement, then that likely accounts for a lot of the description.
So, something as simple as positioning could be behind the different descriptions of such things.
As I have not used the Aeris in my home I will refrain from further comment. :)