OP,
This is absolutely true… providing you are fully assessing the sound correctly and not being swayed by a couple attributes and ignoring others.
It is easy to be seduced by detail and slam, letting rhythm and pace, musicality, and natural sound slip through your fingers. You end up with spectacular highlighted cymbals, chest thumping kick drums and silent background, but sound that misses soul… the emotional connection.
This is why a lot of us old codgers moved back to tubes and companies that are all about the music and not sonic aerobatics.