Bravia KDL46-NX810 vs Samsung UN46C8000XF


Not that the ole CRT has kicked the bucket, but I'm seriously looking at HD TVs. While I'm convinced that plasma offers superior PQ, I don't think it will work in our home environment: lots of windows. Set will be used for an even mix of movies, daily tv (news, wife's fave shows, sports for me), gaming, and internet content. PQ would be my overriding factor. Any help would be appreciated from this HDTV newbie.
jlamb

Showing 1 response by dg1968

To the OP-

Will your new set be going in the same room/location as your old CRT? If so, it is difficult to imagine that light and glare will be much more of a problem with a plasma than they were with your CRT.

We have been all-plasma since about 2004, and never have thought twice about glare issues when locating the sets. IMO glare issues with plasma vs. LCD are far overblown.

Also IMO, there is no comparison between plasma and LCD/LED LCD regarding PQ-- especially with sports. Several of our neighbors have newer LCDs, and personally I just cannot stand the cartoonish image ("soap opera effect") of these sets, even when the proper adjustments are made to address it. However, many people do not seem to be bothered by this at all (or even see it), even when I try to point it out (which I'm sure must get annoying).

Specifically regarding this issue, the Sony sets I've seen have a more natural picture than the Samsungs.

I know it would be a pain, but perhaps you could purchase a plasma from a dealer with a good return policy, if it truly does not work in your location?

Good luck