Not familiar with Amazon but did use Tidal for a while. Left tidal for reasons other than music quality.
Don’t know what you’re experiencing but Tidal is basicly CD quality. Generally there is not much "better" from what tidal provides. I’m guessing there is something different in how you stream it or perhaps for this one song Tidal has chosen an inferior master to upload.
Try other songs.
Look at the streaming path for both.
Jerry