Yeah, I think it’s likely your amp isn’t up to the task. As far as Watts, it’s about headroom and allowing the amp to work in its comfort zone. Many amps will not be at their best when being pushed to deliver near their max output level, and it’s good to have extra power in reserve for when loud peaks occur in the music. If you’re running near an amp’s peak power level it can sound “strained” whereas if you’ve got plenty of power there will be more a sense of “effortless” sound. Hope this helps answer your question. If it was me I’d hop on this if it’s in your budget — awesome amp that will drive the crap outta your Maggies...
https://www.usaudiomart.com/details/649833271-mccormack-dna-225-power-amp/