Auralic Aries G1 Streamer / MHDT Pagoda Balanced DAC - is a Lumin T3 an upgrade?


Hi,

My current set up on the digital front is a G1 Aries with an upgraded Hoer power supply feeding an MHDT Pagoda Balanced DAC - fully balanced throughout the chain.  I’ve got a Zesto Leto Pre and a Krell Illusions ii Pre - I change them in and out - they feed a Krell XD 300 Duo, speakers are Alta Audio Alec’s.  
 

So my question is, would a Lumin T3 be an upgrade, downgrade or lateral move?  I had a Lumin D2 with the S/booster - was impressed, the current set up was a step up for sure.  I tried the Lumin as a streamer only, adding in the G1 definitely was a step up.  My experience with Lumin is their design / build quality / attention to sound quality driving every decision puts them in rarified air when it comes to streamers / DAC’s.  
 

Is it a crazy idea to potentially switch to a 1 box solution?  I have also tried my G1 direct into my Krell DAC - prefer the Pagoda - more open, spacious, extended and analogue sounding. 
 

App wise - I find Auralic and Lumin to be on par with each other - not as functional as Bluos or Roon but livable, functional with a nice suite of options. 
 

Thanks in advance for everyone’s thoughts.  Happy New Year! 

mm1tt77

Showing 1 response by mm1tt77

Hi Sunshdw,

Thanks for the response.  I am trying toweigh if shifting back to an all in one solution would be an overall upgrade in SQ vs the separate units I have today.  With the thought I could, if I wanted to, sell the G1 and the MHDT to help the upgrade.  Keeping the 2 separate does provide more flexibility, most who have some experience with the Pagoda lean toward it punching above it’s weight class, that I’d need to spend quite a bit more to really see a jump, assuming I like the sound signature of the Pagoda.

I guess the million dollar question is around synergy - would Auralic or Lumin or others who offer 1 box solutions in the mid to higher tier of their product portfolio offer a synergy streamer / DAC that is really tough to achieve in seperates unless you spend quite a bit more money. 
 

l really liked the Lumin D2 for the price it performed really well, especially with the upgraded power supply.  I like the Auralic App slightly better than Lumin and the flexibility of being able to stream Amazon Music / slightly more flexibility on the DSP front.  When I did switch to the separates - the Auralic was noticing better feeding other DAC’s than the Lumin but I think the Lumin’s streamer only capabilities were an after thought, only 1 digital out.  
 

Am I placing too much weight on synergy when it comes to streamer / DAC one box solutions?  Should I assume a quality streamer paired with a DAC that has the sound signature I like is always ping to trump the 1 box solution or the majority of the time?  The Pagoda synergistically is designed to be used balanced, it for sure performs at a noticeably higher standard when used in a balanced system. 
 

Thanks,