I have a Schiit DAC but all other gear is ARC. I am getting curious if I should try an ARC DAC and feel just as you, OP! I don't mind a bit to buy used at a reasonable price and resell if it doesn't work out. Why are people always so judgmental on here??? You asked for a comparison, not..."should I do this".
What did you end up trying and what are you listening to nowadays?