You would be moving from a 5th Gen moving coil to more modest, albeit impeccably executed design. Still, I can't imagine you'd be happy with the results. A-T carts aren't really known for the two characteristics you mention - dynamics and soundstage. If the replacement cost is the issue, then I'd consider a Hana ML. In my personal experience, and in every review I've read, Hana carts are extreme overachievers, easily comparable to anything 3X-5X their price.
AT-OC9XMLvs AT-OC9XSH
Any experience comparing these carts? Is there really a difference in stylus shape between the two?
I have owned a few OC9ML and was not disappointed.
I'm looking for a new cart coming off of a Lyra Skala and don't expect quite that refinement but would like equal or improved dynamics. Also looking for solid imaging and a good soundstage.
Arm is a Jelco TK-850L on a severely modified VPI TNT. All Herron Audio electronics.