AT 33SA or OC9 for 1200 mk5


Been trying to narrow down a cart after my 301 mk2 received damage. I extended my budget to include the 33SA, but have been going back and forth with the Shibata and Micro line stylus.

The PTG/2 was at the top of my list until I started hearing more about the 33SA. However I have spoken with a few people about their bias towards the OC9XSL which then gets debated in a few threads over the OC9 with the micro line stylus.

My phonostage is a Phonomena 2, I have the 12g Zupreme headshell but still have the stock headshell if needed, upgrades include the Cardas rewire.

Smooth top end and controlling sibliance is a high priority, seems most AT carts in this range do this while some are better than others.

What started as what I thought was an easy choice has my head in circles..lol.

I'm not well versed on how cart compliance affects the end result if cart choice is not carefully selected.

All input appreciated.
dyl71

Showing 2 responses by tablejockey

Ultimately, your ears will determine what is "best"
I've used the OC9III. Great cart for the price, if your referring to that model, before the many iteration of new OC9  that were introduced last year. The OC9II is even little less$ and purportedly "better" than the III. Either way, for the price it's a good value.
https://www.lpgear.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=SRCH

I haven't heard/read anything on the newer OC9's. Likely all good, for their price point.

If you can up your game a few more, the ART9 is unquestionably a step above. Read the threads.I've used one off an on the past 5 years. Presently on my table.

Save your obsession/audio nervosa regarding compliance. Just get an AT whatever and enjoy the ride.
"I’ve heard that from a couple people... I’m also a believer in "buy once cry once" also so that doesn’t help my budget...lol."
dyk71- I get it. Audio as a hobby, can be a wallet breaker.The great thing about any AT cart, is there is a model for most price points.