2. digital
  3. 1285055559

Anyone tried ripping SACD as 24bit PCM?

I came across this device that extracts 24bit PCM from HDMI interface.

Atlona HD570

When used with SACD player capable of converting DSD to PCM through HDMI, this device can extract the PCM audio stream and redirect to S/PDIF. I'm currently converting my CD, DVD Audio and HDAD collection to FLAC to be used with computer transport and Ayre QB-9 DAC. I haven't found any solution for ripping my 100+ SACD besides extracting the redbook layer which is clearly inferior to the SACD layer. If this device really works, this could be the solution for extracting hires layer from SACD.

It looks like Oppo is a popular platform for this use. However there has been a report that Oppo converts DSD to PCM only in 24/88. Obviously this approach will depend highly on the SACD player, as DSD to PCM conversion will occur in the decoder chip used in the SACD player. I don't have Oppo, but I have the first gen PS3 capable of playing SACD, and also Sony XA5400ES SACD player. I think PS3 could work with this device, although I'm not sure about the quality of decoded PCM audio stream. Does anyone know of XA5400ES is capable of converting DSD to PCM through HDMI output?

My goal is to convert DSD to either 24/88 or 24/96 PCM without losing too much quality, then record the PCM as FLAC using my Macbook Pro. Then the archived files will be served by JRiver music server. Has anyone attempted anything like this?
jylee
8 responses Add your response
esmith3671
30 posts
 
I don't have an answer to your question however, what do you think of this?

MYTEK DIGITAL ( a US manufacturer of digital audio converters ) will release a DAC 4Q 2010 for around $1500 retail, they are available for pre-order right now. Aside from basic capabilities of handling hi-rez PCM files (up to 24/192), it will let you play native DSD files directly from your hard drive.
kr4's avatar
kr4
3,678 posts
 
Yes, it has been done. See http://www.computeraudiophile.com/forum for many who have.

Kal
kijanki's avatar
kijanki
4,428 posts
 
Jylee - DSD in SACD is PWM done at 2.8MHz. Quality wise it should be equal to 20/96 but as far as I remember resolution of the modulator is in order of 8 bits and higher resolution is achieved by dithering. Converting it to PCM on digital side would require to read asynchronous signal without any slightest timing errors possibly not getting better quality than redbook layer. It is possible to A/D analog signal to PCM but then you have extra conversion.

Esmith3671 - Hard drive is not operating in real time. I'm not sure if you can store DSD there the same way you can on SACD on tape. Getting SACD to hard drive is difficult since there is no SACD computer drives. In addition there is strong copy protection and pit-width modulation that drive has to be able to read.
jylee OP
306 posts
 
I understand there could be timing implication when converting from / to digital and analog. Will there be a concern for timing issue even when converting one digital format to another digital format?
kijanki's avatar
kijanki
4,428 posts
 
"Will there be a concern for timing issue even when converting one digital format to another digital format?"

Yes, if analog level is encoded as time interval (Pulse Width Modulation). I guess it can be converted from 1-bit DSD stream if decoder can do digital dithering(filtering) at 2.8MHz

One advantage of SACD, other than equivalent 20/96 quality is the fact that DSD in SACD is recorded without antialias filters normally used before traditional A/D converters to prevent aliasing (signal frequencies larger than half of sampling frequency will fold starting at 0Hz). These filters screw-up transient response that plays big role in spacial clues (transients are used by brain for spacial localization). DSD uses no antialias filter preserving original transients. I'm not sure if this advantage is kept while converting to PCM.
esmith3671
30 posts
 
Kijanki: I wasn't suggesting a way to rip SACDs.
kijanki's avatar
kijanki
4,428 posts
 
Esmith3671 - I know you were only talking about playback but I wish I could load SACD to my hard disk and play them without loss of quality.
crna39's avatar
crna39
145 posts
 
Just download the titles from HDtracks we've done from SACD.
Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
Esoteric Grandioso K1XSE
80x80
Totaldac D1- Direct DAC
80x80
MBL 1621A and 1511