"...and I don't take any advertiser money..."


"As usual, this review is not sponsored (nor does any company get to preview anything I review), and I don’t take any advertiser money from any companies I review."

This is from a review of a Garmin sports watch. Do you think any audio reviewers can make this statements?

Jerry

carlsbad2

@audition__audio:  I have NEVER accepted cash or any kind of direct payment from a manufacturer or distributor and neither have my colleagues - we'd be fired unceremoniously by our publisher if we did. I once was asked how much it would cost for a review; I told the person we don't work that way and explained our system. Be cynical all you want but I can review audio gear and still look at myself in the mirror each day without shame.

@tomic_601: I suppose you can say I try to influence purchases, but I look at it as attempting to steer audio aficionados to equipment that is good value, offers great sound and is well built. If I hadn't been a real fan of good audio for as long as I have (let's just say a long time), I wouldn't do what I do. 

As I've said before, I can't speak for any other reviewer. What they do is beyond my knowledge. I only know the criteria to which I adhere, and I've tried to lay those out in these posts. I'm just trying to clear up misinformation and, I hope, some of the incredible cynicism about reviews and reviewers I see on this forum

@realgoodsound 

Can you blame the cynicism when even Stereophile, the standard publication, passes pure unfiltered manufacturer’s talking points to its readers as a legit review?

You’ve said you haven’t read Stereophile in a long time but still, your surprise that folks are feeling disillusioned vis-a-vis the... objectivity of hifi reviewers is kind of surprising

It depends on where they use the manufacturer's talking points. As I said before, it's my opinion if they're used in a description of the product, I see no problem. If they use them in the actual review section without any justification or substantiation, then I think it's a problem. I don't read either Stereophile or The Absolute Sound for a couple reasons: all the gear they review is out of my ability to buy and I don't like their sometimes, over-the-top language. I just wish they'd stick to facts without the overblown prose and in some cases, what I believe are debatable claims. But that's just my opinion and we all know how valuable opinions are . . . .