I for one like getting the good with the bad as it helps me gain perspective of the product being duscussed, after you get the players involved identified it adds even more substance to their given comments. Enjoy the music.
An idea for threads discussing controversial topics e.g. tweaks.
It would be nice to be able to read those threads and learn about ACTUAL LISTENING experience of people with whatever is being discussed while being able to skip the posts with ridicule or theories of why it can’t work. One idea, at the top of your post type:
"MY LISTENING EXPERIENCE" (then hit shift return to skip a line) then followed by whatever you wish to post.
Anyone can start any post this way, but any post that starts with "MY LISTENING EXPERIENCE" that does non contain actual listening experience is by definition not simply someone trying to be helpful..
One could also title posts "THEORY" for discussions of why/how such things work, for those who are interested. Skeptics/naysayers can legitimately post here.