Am I the only one who thinks B&W is mid-fi?


I know that title sounds pretencious. By all means, everyones taste is different and I can grasp that. However, I find B&W loudspeakers to sound extremely Mid-fi ish, designed with sort of a boom and sizzle quality making it not much better than retail quality brands. At price point there is always something better than it, something musical, where the goals of preserving the naturalness and tonal balance of sound is understood. I am getting tired of people buying for the name, not the sound. I find it is letting the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. In these times of dying 2 channel, and the ability to buy a complete stereo/home theater at your local blockbuster, all of the brands that should make it don't. Most Hi-fi starts with a retail system and with that type of over-processed, boom and sizzle sound (Boom meaning a spike at 80Hz and sizzle meaning a spike at 10,000Hz). That gives these rising enthuists a false impression of what hi-fi is about. Thus, the people who cater to that falseified sound, those who design audio, forgetting the passion involved with listening, putting aside all love for music just to put a nickle in the pig...Well are doing a good job. Honestly, it is just wrong. Thanks for the read...I feel better. Prehaps I just needed to vent, but I doubt it. Music is a passion of mine, and I don't want to have to battle in 20 yrs to get equipment that sounds like music. Any comments?
mikez

Showing 1 response by loose

Without a doubt, B&W speakers are FAR from top notch sound.

I have been on the lookout for a new set of speakers to replace my NHT 2.5i's (which sound pretty darned good, but somewhat sterile) I'm replacing them b/c my current room is actually too small for them (they need room to breathe).

Listened to B&W's (804's, I think) with a variety of amps (bryston 4bst, musical fidelity (not sure which), anthem). While I was certainly able to distinguish sonic attributes amongst the amps, the speakers were very, VERY disappointing. Sure, they are able to set up a semi - 3d soundstage, but overall the sound was flat, lacklustre and veiled. These speakers lacked in dynamics and overall performance left me wondering why anyone would spend so much money on the B&W line.

Maybe it's just my taste (which I admit is very likely). But in my opinion, I can find much MUCH better sound at a fraction of the cost.

And no, I'm not new to the audio game. I've been fiddling with this stuff for 17 years, so I do know what I'm looking for.