A controversial takes on low cost speakers with a lesson...


A controversial takes on 5 speakers comparison with an acoustic lesson few will catch:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pz5tSjE4afM

mahgister

It seems that some had not understood the lesson this naive audiophile go trough...

He discover that room acoustic even if it is only speakers location makes the greatest differences between speakers in a similar bracket price ...

 Qualifying him of trolling is preposterous...

My thread is not, nor this youtube video, motivated by trolling...

I have little patience for this accusations by the way....

 

It is acoustics the greatest factor and the more impactful one ....Especially if we compare speakers in the same bracket price...

 

 As a personal anecdote:

My friend own big  Magnepan in a living room with no acoustics control...

My past speakers  Mission in my acoustics controlled room were way better  than his Magnepan...

To be clear the Magnepan well installed acoustically will beat the hell of my Mission...(  but he was only able to  produce a wall of sound where i was able to create a sound completely enveloping the listener from all side not because Mission speakers are better than Magnepan, they are not, but because of the power of acoustics parameters control)

Then compared to a living room with no acoustic optimization for the Magnepan, my Mission in a very good optimization room for them beat them by a huge margin...

 

The lesson of this video is a beginners audiophile discover the power of acoustics..

Not the law of diminishing return...

Not the overpricing of speakers...

Not the way to troll ....

It is why i used this video...

I dont like accusation of trolling...

 

 

when I said "Pure trolling" it was referencing the dumb video not the post. But I doubt it will help.

@gano I got your point. This is an interesting guy. As you say, seems to know a lot about cameras. He makes lots of camera videos, a random audio video and, apparently, sells what he calls "luxury hot sauce"- its called Oliveum and is very pricey. No word on whether cheap sauce from China is just as hot.

It is evident that this man in this video is not a mature audiophile but an ordinary beginner not a "troll" as you seem to be with few others here derailling the thread with no positive comment...

I did not used this video to troll myself as you insinuated qualifying the video of "dumb video" then attributing this quality by extension to me the OP  when i  used it to speak about acoustics importance and meanings....

I will takes back the apology i gave you few days ago thinking that you were a good faith person...

The underlined part of your post reveal how hypocrital you are and conscious about the way to push the right button to derail my thread with some others which with you banded  with...

I gave you no respect for that and for your past trolling against me either...

 

 

when I said "Pure trolling" it was referencing the dumb video not the post. But I doubt it will help.