I've been saying this to anyone who will listen, if the new formats do not improve on the flaws of broadcast HD (namely compression artifacts) then I will not buy them.
If its true BR is flawless in the PQ area and HD-DVD suffers from the same problems, then for me the choice is easy.
If its true BR is flawless in the PQ area and HD-DVD suffers from the same problems, then for me the choice is easy.