A case for running speakers full range - Tekton Double Impact SE w/ SVS SB16 subs


I've finally had more time to experiment more and contrary to what I normally hear/read, I find running my speakers full range and adding the subs at 50hz sounds much better than relieving the speakers of <50hz activity. 

I see zero effects less dynamics, in fact i feel much more. I feel like the narrative of relieving the amp of the low freq creates more dynamics is probably just a theory created by people who have their speakers set up wrong or are using very small speakers.  

I definitely agree with rolling off bookshelf speakers because they don't play well low anyway, but I'm not sure I agree with cutting off big speakers that can dig low.. I say let them dig low, then let the subs barely augment.


dtximages

Showing 2 responses by millercarbon

The number one problem in getting good bass in a room is low frequency waves are very long, this creates powerful modes, and lumpy slow muddy bass is the result. The modes move around the room depending on where the bass drivers are located. So the answer is to have bass drivers at lots of different locations. There are still modes and so the bass from any one driver is still lumpy, but by having a lot of them each one is at a much lower level where it causes fewer problems and they all add together resulting in powerful smooth articulate bass. 

This being the case is why its better to run the mains full range. They may not have as good low bass as the subs, but to the extent they have any bass output at all it helps average into and smooth out the overall response. Smooth bass is fast bass. 

The subs don't have to be spread out. One of the white papers on this mentions four subs basically stacked on on top of the other. Inevitably they cannot all be in exactly the same location, and to the extent they are different each one produces a different set of modes. The effect is maximized by spreading asymmetrically around the room. But its very good even when that isn't done.  
Its better to run full range, for the simple reason that the more bass sources the better. This is the principle on which Distributed Bass Array is based, that more subs is better than few. This is another one where people have repeated something that looks good on paper (relieve amp/speakers) even though it works poorly (if at all) in practice.