2nd video kind of, but both have problems (more).
Difficult to judge "on a whole" from a Youtube source with your videos as I've never listened to your speakers in person.
However, with speakers/drivers I'm familiar with (and with well, IMO, recorded videos) I am more able to judge such (on a whole - which is not what I understand you are asking about).
I have been using vintage wide band single drivers for the past 20 years, so have a bit of a grip on what you have been working at.
I once considered purchasing a pair of SMGA's that you advertised locally (I'm in West Hollywood).
I didn't go for the SMGA's (owned a pair before) because we had recently acquired a ferocious feral male cat, otherwise I would have contacted you.
A few weeks later we acquired a ferocious feral female Orange cat, so I'm doubly grateful that I did not respond to your ad.
Anyway, good luck with the show.
DeKay