New Tom Petty

Shadorne,

I just played my Bluray for the first time and I concur with your assessment. The CD is most notable -IMHO- for what it lacks: compression. It appears to have been recorded at a significantly lower level than most of this ilk, and - for me - must be cranked to appreciate. It also offers a nice sense of space and air around the performers.

The Bluray sounds quite similar, but adds a more obvious dynamic quality, evident at lower SPLs. Still not demo quality to my ear, but awfully, awfully good for what is essentially a "bar band" style recording.

Regarding the Mojo BD, dynamics are similar to Tom Waits Heart Attack and Vine CD. Recordings of such high quality are extremely rare these days.

Some may not like the "live" sound - so opinions can vary - no doubt some will hate it.

Although, it may not make the demo shortlist purely because it lacks careful manipulation, reverb, overdubs etc. It is a very "honest" recording and sounds about as realistic as it gets.

As a recording that sounds like the band actually does sound (when playing live) - this is recording is definitely exceptional.

Shadorne: What a diplomatic response! You're my hero!

Audifeil,
regarding the no rap thing, if you listen to most of Dr.Dre's production work with Eminim, the slight musical nuances that build up in the background you would be very impressed. I suggest the Marshal Matthews LP to start, listen to whats going on behind the vocals.
I can also suggest you try The Nappy Roots catalog, very musical.
Your missing out on a lot of great stuff, Beastie Boys etc but hey, it's your record collection, not mine.

If Rap didn't have vocals and the dreadful thump, thump, thump it might be tolerable.