@jereeb - What cables are you running from the turntable to the phono-pre? Is it possible that they are picking up the 60Hz hum from one of the power cords, the AC wiring in the wall, close by power suppy, etc. I had a problem once where I was picking up EM interference from a nearby radio station on the cables from my VPI table and the phono-pre. I could actually hear the radio program/music. I switched to a set of shielded cables and it went away.
I've also heard, somewhere a long time ago and I don't remember where, that some Grado cartridges are susceptible to EMI. Might be complete bs, but might be possible.
Just a thought.