To Repair or Replace

Dump the Icon, for parts. If you like the Cal Tube sound look for a used Alpha/Delta unit, maybe even one with a 96k mod. I have both an Alpha and Sigma II and it sounds better then my Sony SCD on red book cd's.

An economist would say this is a simple decision. If you can buy something you like just as well for $350 or less, then replace. If something else costs more than $350, then repair.

However, you should also factor in that even with a new laser, you have thirteen years of wear and tear on the mechanical elements of the player, i.e. drawer and disc motor. That would make me a bit nervous. I think maybe you should start shopping around a bit.

Technology has vastly improved with digital. I replace an older Krell with a much newer Marantz because it sounded so much better. I didn't even try the newer Krell digital because my son is in private school and I couldn't afford it even if I liked it.

(All my other electronics remain Krell)

Richard

Thanks for all the sound advice. I think I knew the answer to my own question but sometimes you just have to bounce the idea of someone else for validation.
After reading the thread about the Sony PS1 I found one in a local pawn shop for $15 so I'm going to explore that before moving forward. Who knows, I may have just saved myself a LOT of money. :) Thanks again.

Jhuser,

Are you brave enough to attempt a DIY replacement of the laser mechanism? I have recently done this, successfully (!!), in my Delta. The most challenging part was finding a source for the replacement mechanism. The cost for parts was about US$80. This mechanism included motors and other mechanical parts that spin the CD and move the laser head.

Some more details can be found in the lower half of this thread (posts by Silica).

http://www.diyaudio.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=26009

Good Luck!

Silica