Passive Bookshelf Speaker Selection


Putting together a first set-up for exclusively turntable listening. I have narrowed things down to the Fluance RT-85 and NAD C 316BEE but am getting stuck with passive bookshelf speakers. Originally was set on the Klipsch RP-600ms but am having second thoughts given concerns about the potential fatigue and overbearing brightness; I’m wondering if I should go for another option in the $500 range or stick with the Klipsch, which I can get for under 500. I’m considering the KEF Q150s, PSB Alpha P5s, ELAC Debut 2.0 B6.2s, and B&W 607s. Looking for good dynamics that aren’t overwhelming but also warmth.  

Ideally, I’d love to go test any of these out but that’s unfortunately not an option right now. 

I listen mostly to rock and indie/alternative, and the room is roughly 13x17 ft. 


Should I get the Klipsch or head in a different direction? Any help would be appreciated. 


thisisnotfortears
Why not consider used gear? That would greatly expand your possibilities.

Also, something like the Elac Debut 2.0 B6 is inexpensive enough to just go buy and if not suitable can be turned over to another motivated buyer for, probably, close to what you paid. 

Have you considered Tekton? The Mini Lore is currently selling at $575, delivered.
I have a pair of PSB Imagine B's idle since I recently purchased the PSB T2's. They were originally $1089.00 and I will sell them for $500 if you are interested in used bookshelf speakers. PSB is the sister company to NAD and should work great with your NAD 316 bee.
I own these and can recommend them for neutral sound - NHT SuperOne 2.1, NHT C3, Elac UB5. Just remember one person's neutral is another's dark or forward. I recently heard the Focal Chora 826 and did not think it was bright or overly detailed, so perhaps that will give you an idea of my neutral.  

However, the speakers I listed are 85-87 db so may not play as loud as you want with a lower power amp. (I did not look up the power rating of your NAD pick). 

Good luck with your search. You have to start somewhere so pick one with good reviews and go with it for a year or so, then consider adding to your speaker collection.

You should get whatever electronics aside from speakers first.  After that is all set up, buy speakers from someone who will let you return them if you don't like the sound.  Also you could try the used speaker market and some of those dealers will also allow returns.  NHT SB3's are really good, if you can find a pair.
I heard a crazy good pair of paradigm, a brand I usually find to bright, but this pair listed for $600 and rocked!