Religious music for less than devout

There is also Pie Jesu done by many  and written by Andrew Lloyd Webber at the loss of his father, sung well by Anna Netrebko on her Souvenir album and by Sissel. Both can be heard on u-tube. A gorgeous song. 
O Magnum Mysterium written by Morton Lauridsen is also beautiful. It can be found on Lauridsen’s CD Lux Aeterna on the RCM label and also it is done by Robert Shaw on the CD named O Magnum Mysterium on Telarc.
Again, anything Bach. To Bach,” The aim and final end of all music should be none other than the glory of God and the refreshment of the soul.”
I would self-label as devout, but, like n80, I really don’t like popular Christian music, though the old hymns still stir the heart.
John

For irreverence, "God May Forgive You (But I Won't)", written by Harlan Howard & Bobby Braddock. I have it in recordings by both Iris Dement and Rosie Flores, both great.

I love Lee Ann Womack's music, and many of her songs are Christian oriented.
I particularly like All His Saints, and her collaboration with The Fairfield Four - Children Go Where I Send Thee

All Things Must Pass

 I was wondering when someone was going to bring George Harrison into the conversation. Most all his music (single performer) post The Beatles was religious in a very strong, yet sometimes subtle way, and sometimes not: ‘My Sweet Lord’, as example. He became a Hindu during the last years of the Beatles, and stayed so until his death.

Igor Stravinsky's - "Symphony of Psalms"
(choral intro to the 3rd movement is otherworldly)

Hestitate adding this because it is so obvious, but don't think I saw it mentioned: Handel's "Messiah"

Thanks to the OP for starting the thread.  
I appreciated n80's comments about his faith (shared, I will add).