I have had both...preferred Herron ran wide open. Both are very good phono’s. But it is all about preferences. I am currently using a SUT into my Audio Tekne preamp with built in phono. I would pass on the VPI but I am biased to the Garrard 301 and Thorens TD-124 tables. 3k would buy me a Technics SL-1200g but I am also a fan of detachable Headshells as well....if you go with the VPI try and secure one with the 3D arm. I can speak to VPI as I owned a Prime Signature and kept it a short time as it just wasn’t for me.
Good Luck in your search:)
Good Luck in your search:)