BAT VK 5i and tubes, how to chosse?

I'd post this is AudioAsylum.com under amps/pre section. Victor, one of the BAT owners, and the designer, usually replies.

I have Amperex 7308's Orange globe logo in my BAT vkp10se phono stage. Sounds wonderful...replaced the stock sovtek 6922's...

George,

I have found that the BAT preamps don't care for the 6DJ8s. I have tried the Bugle Boys and they were fine for about 10 minutes and then things got noisy. If your determined to roll some different tubes into the 5i I would recommend a 7308.

You may think I am joking here, but I am not. I have had good luck with Sylvania/Phillips JAN 6922 which you can buy from PartsExpress.com for $7 each.

The Phillips JANs work fine, as do the Sovtek 6H23s. Better 6922s or 7308s work even better. If you are interested in some 6H23s with very few hours on them, contact me off-thread and maybe we can work something out.

I have tried a ton of different tubes in the VK5i. I found no problems with the 6DJ8, but mostly I used 6922's I actually prefered Mullard over Amperex. For what it's worth to my ears there wasn't much difference between the high buck Amprex's and the less expensive Bugle Boys.

I found out something very interesting though. You can achieve excellent results by only replacing the 2 very outside tubes ( towards the front ). I found this to take that bit of glare of the mids, and highs that the Sovteks had. And also it was much cheaper to only replace 2 vs 6! In replacimg only the 2, I found Telefunken to be the best choice.

Another thing you can try is to replace the two 5881's ( you can use 6L6 tubes here ) In this case I liked Sylvania 6L6GC's But there were many others that produced a pleasing tone.

Of course all of this happened in my system, and with my taste for sonics and music.