You get what you pay for...


That statement is usually the case. Not always in audio, but in most of the other things in life. Well, here's my story... I picked up a new Cambridge D500 SE CD player in February. I was in the market, and had been waiting for the format war to shake out a bit more than it had. Well, it was past time to upgrade, so I decided to make my move. I didn't feel it to be smart to buy an expensive CD player. At least, right now. So, I looked around, I happened upon the Cambridge. It was a breath of fresh air! A great sound, better than anything else I came across at its price point. And as good as most of the other players I checked out, which happened to be anywhere from two to four times more expensive. Good dynamics, weight, pace, tone, resolution, detail, etc. I figured that corners were cut in the areas of cosmetics, the front panel/case, and the fact that the players were manufactured in China. I didn't think that build quality would be one of the corners that were cut, as the unit seemed to be quite robust and nicely constructed. Well, all was well and I was happy as a clam. Until, I started to encounter a few problems with output. The first time, I had no output at all. The second time, output was filled with static. Both lasted for a day or so. Then, there was no output for about 4 days. I talked to my dealer, and he told me that we should send it in. That something could have happened in shipping, etc. Something like a board being hairlined cracked or whatever. Well, to their credit Cambridge told him to just give me a new player. Very nice of them, and excellent customer service. As my girlfriend wanted silver this time, it had to be ordered. Yesterday, I picked it up and all was great again. Until I took it home. I hooked it up in the kitchen, just to look at the very attractive blue display. After tinkering around with it, I opened the drawer. Upon trying to close it, it would not go. Due to misalignment. It got stuck right where the door lines up with the fascia. It would slide in by me forcing it over, but that is not how an out of the box player should be(and that's an understatement). So, I went back, and my dealer had another one ready for me. But, I decided that after having two bad players in the course of a few short months, my faith in the company has been destroyed. He tried to blame shipping again, but we know better. A door does not get moved out of whack during shipping, where it is safely in the closed position. The door is cemented in, and this one was simply misaligned. Despite QC which supposedly tests(via playing) each and every player before going out the door, this one was allowed to ship. I was offered another Cambridge player(which I now do not feel comfortable in taking), my money to be used anywhere else in the store, or a refund. Each of which is good customer service by my dealer, himself being a model of what a dealer should aspire to. I do need a player, but do not want to spend more money to reach the same level of sonic quality. Also don't want to buy inferior sound at the same price. I guess what I am saying is that I am now in a quandry. As my dealer will be on vacation for the next 10 days(and I told him I will hold off making a choice until he returns), it will give me some time to divorce myself from the original disappointment and make a better decision. I guess I am just venting here. My question is, has anyone else encountered any gremlins from Cambridge? Any other comments anyone would like to offer up would certainly be appreciated. Thank you in advance
trelja

Showing 1 response by trelja

Thanks for all the responses. My previous player was a Pioneer PD-5100, made in Japan. Quality is obviously several levels higher, as I never had a problem and build quality never came into question. It simply works. Just like a sewing machine. Will probably run forever.

I discovered the IEC problem, during one of the fits of my first Cambridge player. In my case, it is NOT due to the power cord, as I never even removed the included power cord from its bag. I used two other power cords I had previously bought. When all else failed, I inserted the player in a different system, and it worked. Then I put it back in my main system and all was OK, for a while. It seems from all the horror stories I have previously seen(on AudioReview) and here, that the quality of Cambridge gear is just not up to snuff. Therefore, I will not be taking a chance on another D500 SE. Again, I do really, really like the sonics. But, the player has to work in order for me to enjoy the sound. Other players my dealer carries are:
1. NAD 541. Same price point. Inferior sonics. Less heft, resolution, detail, and refinement.
2. Jolida 603. Same price point. Seems to be of sloppy build quality. Inferior sonics. A fair amount of haze, grunge, and murk. Not sure if it is due to the stock Chinese 12AX7s, but build quality now scares me.
3. Rega Planet 2000. 2X more expensive. My dealer is not in love with the build, but it seems good to me. Sonics are sluggish and boring to me.
4. Linn Ikemi. 4X+ more expensive. Sonics are about equivalent. Very open and detailed, lack of weight and heft. I am certain it exhibits typical Linn excellent build quality.
5. Electrocompaniet. Not sure about price(it's not cheap...). Excellent sound and build quality. Not sure one could expect more.
6. Linn Genki. Expensive, have not listened to it.

Basically, the only players I would be happy with from this list are the Linn Ikemi and Electrocompaniet. But, I am not going to spend that much on a CD player. Not when I am uncertain of the future status of the new formats. Or, if they will take off within the next year or so.

Maybe I will take something else from the store, even though my system is pretty much complete(I don't need anything other than a CD player). I would like to support this dealer(via my money), as he has always given me good service, etc. However, in the end there is still a chance I will just opt for the refund, as I do not see a better alternative yet.